Social Norm (talk | contribs) m added a bit to the section on cultural variation |
Social Norm (talk | contribs) m removed sentence about Brazil and Thailand that was either inaccurate or unclear |
||
Line 147: | Line 147: | ||
[[Image:Kathoy1649.jpg|thumb|left|[[Pattaya]]: [[Kathoey]]s on the stage of a [[cabaret]] show.]] |
[[Image:Kathoy1649.jpg|thumb|left|[[Pattaya]]: [[Kathoey]]s on the stage of a [[cabaret]] show.]] |
||
In Thailand, [[kathoey]] (who are often, but not always, transsexual) are accepted to a greater extent than in most countries, but are not completely free of societal stigma. Feminine transsexual kathoey are much more accepted than gay male kathoey; this may be seen as an example of [[heteronormativity]]. Due to the relative prevalence and acceptance of transsexualism in Thailand, there are many accomplished Thai surgeons who specialize in male-to-female sex reassignment surgery. Thai surgeons are a popular option for Western transpeople seeking surgery because of the lower costs. |
|||
Transsexual- (and tg-) related issues remain largely [[taboo]] in much of [[Africa]].<ref>{{cite conference |first=Juliet V. |last=Mukasa |title=Transgender Human Rights Issues in Africa | booktitle = |date=[[2006-10-23]] |location=World International Lesbian and Gay Association (ILGA) PANEL AT 2ND UNCHR SESSION |url=http://www.ilga.org/news_results.asp?LanguageID=1&FileCategoryID=1&FileID=908&ZoneID=7 |accessdate=2006-12-24}}</ref> |
Transsexual- (and tg-) related issues remain largely [[taboo]] in much of [[Africa]].<ref>{{cite conference |first=Juliet V. |last=Mukasa |title=Transgender Human Rights Issues in Africa | booktitle = |date=[[2006-10-23]] |location=World International Lesbian and Gay Association (ILGA) PANEL AT 2ND UNCHR SESSION |url=http://www.ilga.org/news_results.asp?LanguageID=1&FileCategoryID=1&FileID=908&ZoneID=7 |accessdate=2006-12-24}}</ref> |
Revision as of 18:29, 12 April 2009
Part of a series on |
Transgender topics |
---|
Category |
Transsexualism is a condition in which an individual identifies with a physical sex different from the one with which he or she was born. A medical diagnosis can be made if a person experiences discomfort as a result of a desire to be a member of the opposite sex,[1] or if a person experiences impaired functioning or distress as a result of that gender identification.[2] Transsexualism is stigmatized in many parts of the world but has become more widely known in Western culture in the mid to late 20th century, concurrently with the sexual revolution and the development of sexual reassignment surgeries. It remains controversial, however. Discrimination and negative attitudes towards transsexualism often accompany certain religious beliefs or cultural values. There are other cultures, however, that have not only held a place for transsexuals but even sanction them. Some native American tribes accept them as two-spirit people.[3]
Gender Identity Disorder and Transsexualism
"Gender Identity Disorder" and "Transsexualism" both appear in the two major diagnostic manuals used by mental health professionals worldwide, [4][5] the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM) and the "International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems (10th Revision)" (ICD10).[4][5] These terms are used in different ways in the ICD10 and the DSM.[4][5] In the ICD 10, gender identity disorders include "transsexualism", "Dual Role transvestism" and "Gender identity disorder of childhood".[4] Transsexualism is defined in the ICD10 as "A desire to live and be accepted as a member of the opposite sex, usually accompanied by a sense of discomfort with, or inappropriateness of, one's anatomic sex, and a wish to have surgery and hormonal treatment to make one's body as congruent as possible with one's preferred sex."[4] The DSM on the other hand uses "Gender Identity Disorder" as a synonym for transsexualism and defines what it calls "transvestic fetishism" as a separate phenomenon which it says can be present in conjunction with Gender Identity disorder.[5] (page 583) The DSM specifically defines GID the following way.
There are two components of Gender Identity Disorder, both of which must be present to make the diagnosis. There must be evidence of a strong and persistent cross-gender identification, which is the desire to be, or the insistence that one is of the other sex (Criteria A). This cross-gender identification must not merely be a desire for any perceived cultural advantages of being the other sex. there must also be evidence of persistent discomfort about one’s assigned sex or a sense of inappropriateness in the gender role of that sex (Criteria B). The diagnosis is not made if the individual has a concurrent physical inter-sex condition (e.g., androgen insensitivity syndrome or congenital adrenal hyperplasia) (Criteria C). To make the diagnosis, there must be evidence of clinically significant distress or impairment in social, occupational, or other important areas of functioning (Criteria D). [5]
Transsexual men and women desire to establish a permanent social role as a member of the gender with which they identify. Many transsexual people also desire various types of medical alterations to their bodies. These physical alterations are collectively referred to as sex reassignment therapy and may include hormone replacement therapy and surgery. The entire process of switching from one physical sex and social gender presentation to the other is often referred to as transition, and usually takes several years.
Concepts and definitions
The word transsexual was used by [6] Harry Benjamin in his seminal book The Transsexual Phenomenon[6] to describe transsexuals on a scale (later called the "Benjamin Scale") that recognizes levels of intensity of transsexualism: "Transsexual (Nonsurgical)", "True Transsexual (moderate intensity)", and "True Transsexual (high intensity)".[6] Some transsexuals believe that to be considered a "true" transsexual one needs to have a desire for surgery, but Benjamin did not think so.[7] [8] Benjamin suggested that moderate intensity "true transsexuals" (male-to-female) may benefit from estrogen medication as a "substitute for or preliminary to operation."[6] Some people have had SRS but do not meet the common definition of a transsexual (e.g., Gregory Hemingway).[9][10]. While other people do not desire SRS yet they clearly meet Dr. Benjamin's definition of a "true transsexual". [11] Beyond Benjamin's work, which focused on male-to-female transsexuals, there is the case of the Female to male transsexual for whom surgery is not practical.[12]
The two terms of sex and gender are often used as if they were equivalent. However, it can be useful to use “sex” to refer biology and anatomy (male or female), and gender to refer to personal self-identification and social roles (man and woman) (see Milton Diamond, 2001 or U.S.S.C. Justice Antonin Scalia.
Genital surgery is undertaken it is often referred to as "sex reassignment surgery", genital reconstructive surgery or even gender reassignment surgery. Some consider “sex change surgery” to be disrespectful.
The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders accepts the expression of desire to be of the opposite sex, or assertion that one is of the sex opposite from the one with which one was assigned at birth, as sufficient for being transsexual.[13] Similarly, the ICD-10 defines transsexualism as "the desire to live and be accepted as a member of the opposite sex, usually accompanied by the wish to make his or her body as congruent as possible with the preferred sex through surgery and hormone treatment." In contrast, transgenderists do not identify as being of, or desiring to be the opposite sex, but as being of or wanting to be another gender.
Transsexualism has been variously described as a physical disability, a condition, trait, disease, behavior, desire, mental illness, perversion, paraphilia, political identity, and lifestyle.
Transsexualism is often included within the broader term transgender, which is generally considered an umbrella term for people who do not conform to typical accepted gender roles, for example cross-dressers, drag queens, and people who identify as genderqueer. Some transsexuals object to this inclusion. Historically the reason that transsexuals rejected associations with the transgender or broader LGBT community is largely that the medical community in the 1950s through the late 1980s encouraged (and in many ways required) this rejection of such a grouping in order to be a 'good transsexual' who would thus be allowed to access medical and surgical care. The animosity that is present today is no longer fed by this same kind of pressure from the medical community (indeed, today many gender therapists actively encourage their clients to explore support within the broader community.)
However, where some of the beliefs of modern day transsexual people that they are not transgender, is reflective of this historical division (Denny 176), other transsexual people state that someone choosing to retain their former physical sex (no SRS) is very different from someone who needs to be of "the other sex", that the groups have different issues and concerns and are not doing the same things.[8] The latter view is rather contested, with opponents pointing out that merely having or not having some medical procedures hardly can have such far-reaching consequences as to put those who have them and those who have not into such distinctive categories. Notably Harry Benjamin's original definition of Transsexual does not require that they need to have had SRS. [6]
Gender terminology for transsexual people
The word “transsexual” is used most respectfully as an adjective. In other words, one who wishes to be respectful would refer, as this article does, to "transsexual people," "transsexual men," or "transsexual CEOs," rather than referring to an individual as a transsexual.
Transsexual people usually prefer to be referred to by the gender pronouns and terms associated with their target gender. For example, a transsexual man is a person who was assigned the female sex at birth on the basis of his genitals, but despite that assignment identifies as a man and is transitioning or has transitioned to a male gender role and has or will have a masculine body. Transsexual people are sometimes referred to with "assigned-to-target" sex terms such as "female-to-male" for a transsexual man or "male-to-female" for a transsexual woman. These terms may be abbreviated as "M2F", "F2M", "MTF", "F to M", etc. These terms are particularly helpful in preventing confusion, because to some people the term "transsexual woman" is a female transitioning to become a male, and to others a male transitioning to become a female. When the terms transmen and transwomen are used though, it is typical for them to be used to refer to the gender that the person identifies with, regardless of their appearance or state of transition.
Although some do identify as part of the LGBT community, others do not. Transsexual people often feel that gender identity and sexual orientation sexual orientation are not the same thing. Transsexual men and women are of various sexual orientations just as non-transsexual (some times referred to as Cisgender or Cissexual) people are, and they will almost always use terms for their sexual orientation that relate to the sex with which they identify. For example, someone born biologically male who identifies as a woman, and who is attracted solely to men, will commonly identify as heterosexual. Likewise, someone who was born biologically female, identifies as a man, and prefers male partners, will identify as gay, not heterosexual. Transsexual people, like other people, can also be bisexual or asexual as well.
Older medical texts often referred to transsexual people as members of their original sex by referring to a male-to-female transsexual as a "male transsexual". They also described sexual orientation in relation to the person's assigned sex, not their gender of identity; in other words, referring to a male-to-female transsexual who is attracted to men as a "homosexual male transsexual." This usage is considered by many to be scientifically inaccurate and clinically insensitive today. As such someone who would have been referred to as a "homosexual male transsexual" would now be called and most likely identify herself as a heterosexual transsexual woman. Although the original usage is dwindling, some medical textbooks still refer to transsexual people as members of their assigned sex, but now many use "assigned-to-target" terms.
Alternative terminology
Because these terms describe identities, their definitions are contested and usage varies. Some people use terms not discussed here.
The transsexual community typically use the short form "trans", or simply "T" as a substitution for the full word "transsexual", e.g. TS, trans guy, trans dyke, T-folk, trans folk. Some may even use terms that have become controversial to some, such as tranny and/or trans, despite others considering these terms to be offensive. Those who do use these terms claim that they are diminishing the power of the term as an insult, just as some members of the gay and African-American communities have embraced slurs directed at them. Others feel that the terms are insulting or inaccurate regardless of the context. Some feel that such words are problematic because they do not differentiate between transsexual people, and people who are merely "playing" with gender.
Some individuals may prefer to spell transsexual with only one s, i.e., transexual. They may assert that they are attempting to divorce the word from the realm of psychiatry and medicine and place it in the realm of identity. This perspective is most common in the United States, and is almost never used in the United Kingdom.[14]
Some transsexual people may prefer transgender over transsexual, because this minority sees the issue to be about gender rather than sexuality. (Note that this distinction, violating norms of gender vs. violating norms of sex, is precisely why crossdressers, as one of many examples, are classified as transgender rather than transsexual.) This subset of transsexual people make a parallel with intergender, who think of themselves as between the genders rather than between sexes. Some transsexual people think of transsexualism as a subset of intersex. "Intersex" usually refers to people whose genitals are not typically male nor female. Transsexualism, in this view, simply becomes a form of being neurologically intersex that was mistakenly categorized outside of the rubric of intersex because of the historical lack of proof for a specific etiology. (See below for hypotheses on the possible causes of transsexualism.)
The term "Gender Dysphoria" and "Gender Identity Disorder" were not used until the 1970s[15] when Laub and Fisk[16][17] published several works on transsexualism using these terms. "Transsexualism" was replaced in the DSM-IV by "Gender Identity Disorder in Adolescents and Adults".
Some people prefer that transsexualism be referred to as Harry Benjamin's Syndrome[18] as it follows the naming conventions of intersex conditions. This term is named for Harry Benjamin, a pioneer in sex reassignment and research on transsexual people, whose work of the 1950s and 1960s, which culminated in The Transsexual Phenomenon in 1966. Many transsexual people who prefer this term assert that scientific research has strongly suggested that their condition is biological rather than psychological in nature. They also feel that 'trans' is misleading, as they believe that their gender was fixed in their brains, and has never changed. Thus that nothing about their steps in correcting themselves is actually "trans" at all, but rather they are simply taking steps to assert what they feel that they are already. A small number of people who are post operative and living in their chosen role prefer to call themselves either a neo-woman or neo-man, thus omitting references in the term 'transsexual' to sexuality or being in between (trans).
Andrea James proposed the descriptions "interest in feminization" and "interest in masculinization" to refer to a desire for sex reassignment therapy, regardless of whether the person self-identifies as transsexual or not.[19] Others point out that this incorrectly represents transsexuality as a "life-style choice", but many transsexual people feel that their condition has a biological origin. While many feel that transsexuality is not a choice, they think of it as part of normal human variation, rather than as a pathology.[19]
Other languages and cultures
Gender was originally a linguistic term. In many languages, words can be considered masculine, feminine, or neutral, completely independently from the attributes of the things to which the word applies. Different languages manifest gender in various ways, recognizing two genders (female, male), three genders (female, male, neuter), or none at all. In some (e.g. the Romance languages), variation by gender is indicated by relatively simple changes in nouns and adjectives, while others require more complex grammatical changes. In English, a transsexual person's first step in transition often includes the request to be referred to using pronouns for their target gender (he rather than she, him rather than her, and his rather than hers, or vice versa). Some English speakers who feel that they are best described as something in between or other than masculine or feminine prefer to use “ze” and “hir” (examples of gender neutral pronouns in English), or other invented neutral pronouns.
Magnus Hirschfeld coined the term "Transvestite." He described what is now called transvestic fetishism Die Transvestitien as well as transsexualism.[15] In 1930, he supervised the first genital reassignment surgery to be reported in detail in a peer-reviewed journal on Lili Elbe of Denmark. The German term “Transsexualismus” was introduced by Hirschfeld in 1923.[20] The neo-Latin term “psychopathia transexualis” and English “transexual” (sic) were introduced by D. O. Cauldwell in 1949,[21] who subsequently also used the term “trans-sexual” in 1950.[22] Cauldwell appears to be the first to use the term in direct reference to those who desired a change of physiological sex.[23] (In 1969, Benjamin claimed to have been the first to use the term “transsexual” in a public lecture, which he gave in December 1953.[24]) This term continues to be used by the public and medical profession alike.[15] It was included for the first time in the DSM-III in 1980 and again in the DSM-III-R in 1987, where it was located under Disorders Usually First Evident in Infancy, Childhood or Adolescence.
Gender-variant people experience different degrees of acceptance in different cultures. Terms and concepts concerning gender identity and sexuality vary significantly different language or cultural groups. Thus, in some cultures, whether or not a person is considered homosexual depends on what role they take in a sexual interaction, not simply on the sex of their partner. Also, it's dificult to extend western concepts of gender identity and sexuality to a society where being a male homosexual is unacceptable and is penalized, but being a male-to-female transsexual is allowed.
For example, before the Islamic Revolution in 1979, the issue of transsexualism in Iran had never been officially addressed by the government. Beginning in the mid-1980s, however, transsexual individuals have been officially recognized by the government and allowed to undergo sex reassignment surgery (see Transsexuality in Iran), while male same-sex relations are still forbidden.
In Thailand, kathoey (who are often, but not always, transsexual) are accepted to a greater extent than in most countries, but are not completely free of societal stigma. Feminine transsexual kathoey are much more accepted than gay male kathoey; this may be seen as an example of heteronormativity. Due to the relative prevalence and acceptance of transsexualism in Thailand, there are many accomplished Thai surgeons who specialize in male-to-female sex reassignment surgery. Thai surgeons are a popular option for Western transpeople seeking surgery because of the lower costs.
Transsexual- (and tg-) related issues remain largely taboo in much of Africa.[25]
Prevalence
There are no reliable statistics on the prevalence of transsexualism. The DSM-IV (1994) quotes a prevalence of roughly 1 in 30,000 assigned males and 1 in 100,000 assigned females seek sex reassignment surgery in the USA. The most reliable estimate of prevalance is from the Amsterdam Gender Dysphoria Clinic[26] The data, spanning more than four decades in which the clinic has treated roughly 95% of Dutch transsexuals, gives figures of 1:10,000 assigned males and 1:30,000 assigned females.
Olyslager and Conway presented a paper[27] at the WPATH 20th International Symposium (2007) arguing that the data from their own and other studies actually imply much higher prevalence, with minimum lower bounds of 1:4,500 male-to-female transsexuals and 1:8,000 female-to-male transsexuals for a number of countries worldwide. They suggest the prevalence might be as high as 1:500 births overall.
Olyslager and Conway also argued that the U.S. population of assigned males having already undergone reassignment surgery by the top three U.S. SRS surgeons alone is enough to account for the entire transsexual population implied by the 1:10,000 prevalence number. This excludes all other U.S. SRS surgeons, surgeons in countries such as Thailand, Canada, and others, and the high proportion of transsexuals who have not yet sought treatment, suggesting that a prevalance of 1:10,000 is too low.
A presentation at the LGBT Health Summit in Bristol UK [28], based upon figures from a number of reputable European and UK sources, shows that this population is increasing rapidly (14% per year) and that the mean age of transition is actually rising.
Causes of transsexualism
There's not a solid consensus on the cause of transsexuality, nor for any other sexual or gender identity. Psychological and biological causes for transsexualism have been proposed. Some people consider research into the "causes" of transsexualism to be based on the assumption that it is a pathology, an assumption that is rejected by some transsexuals. Others think of the condition as a form of intersexuality, and support research into possible causes, believing that it will verify the theory of a biological origin and thereby reduce social stigma by demonstrating that it is not a delusion, a political statement, or a paraphilia. Note stigma has a role to play in the development of and adherence to both viewpoints. See the transfeminism article's section on GID for further discussion.
Harry Benjamin wrote, "Summarizing my impression, I would like to repeat here what I said in my first lecture on the subject more than 10 years ago: Our genetic and endocrine equipment constitutes either an unresponsive [or] fertile soil on which the wrong conditional and a psychic trauma can grow and develop into such a basic conflict that subsequently a deviation like transsexualism can result."[29]
A few studies based on small samples suggest that transsexualism might be associated with a difference in the human brain called the bed nucleus of the stria terminalis (BSTc). In one study, the BSTc of male-to-female transsexuals and cisgendered women were similar. Those of heterosexual and homosexual men were similar to each other and different from those of women (cis- and transgendered).[30] Another study suggests that transsexuality may have a genetic component.[31]
Diagnosing transsexualism
The current diagnosis for transsexual people who present themselves for psychological treatment is "gender identity disorder" (leaving out those who have sexual identity disorders without gender concerns). As the DSM has changed its terminology, the diagnosis of "transsexualism" has become unused in recent years. This diagnostic label is often necessary to obtain sex reassignment therapy. However, some people diagnosed with gender identity disorder have no desire for sex reassignment therapy at all, particularly not genital reassignment surgery, and/or are not appropriate candidates for such treatment. While some feel that formal diagnosis helps to destigmatize transsexualism, others feel that it only adds stigma, essentially feeling that such a diagnosis is equivalent to saying something really is wrong with them. (Brown 105) Again, see Transfeminism's section on GID.
Some people who desire sex reassignment therapy do not have gender identity disorder, as it's usually understood, and desire to transition for other reasons. This can include homosexual people who are unable to accept their homosexuality (or who were, up until the 1970s, encouraged by caretakers to change their gender role, including SRS), cross-dressers who feel more comfortable dressed as members of the opposite gender and may become confused (although it may be important to realize that many transsexual women go through a period where they self-identify as cross-dressers), and people with certain psychiatric disorders, such as schizophrenia, borderline personality disorder, dissociative identity disorder, and Munchausen syndrome. (Brown 106-107) Most professionals believe that sex reassignment therapy is not appropriate for such individuals, (Brown 107) and SRS is expected to have negative for them.[32].
Some transsexual people may suffer from co-morbid psychiatric conditions unrelated to their gender dysphoria. The DSM-IV itself states that in rare instances, gender identity disorder may co-exist with schizophrenia, and that psychiatric disorders are generally not considered contraindications to sex reassignment therapy, that is unless they are the primary cause of the patient's gender dysphoria. (Brown 108) Despite this permissiveness, the process of psychological treatment is usually much more complicated for transsexual people with co-morbid psychiatric conditions.
Some transsexual people have pressured the American Psychiatric Association to remove Gender Identity Disorder from the DSM. Many of these people feel that at least some mental health professionals are being insensitive by labeling transsexualism as "a disease", rather than as an inborn trait.[33] Furthermore, many people think that some psychologists and psychiatrists in viewing transsexualism as "a disease" have sought to develop specific models of transsexualism, such as Ray Blanchard's model, which they feel exclude many transsexual people.
Sex reassignment therapy
Sex reassignment therapy (SRT) is an umbrella term for all medical procedures regarding sex reassignment of both transgender and intersexual people. Though it is sometimes SRT called "gender reassignment", those who use the word "sex" to describe an individual's biology and "gender" to describe their personal identity and social role consider this usage to be misleading. The process of changing from one gender presentation to another is often called transition.
Individuals make different choices regarding sex reassignment therapy, which can include hormone replacement therapy (HRT) to modify secondary sex characteristics, sex reassignment surgery to alter primary sex characteristics, and permanent hair removal for transwomen. Transsexual people who transition usually change their social gender roles, legal names and legal sex designation.
To obtain sex reassignment therapy, transsexual people are usually required to receive psychological therapy and a diagnosis of gender identity disorder in accordance with the Standards of Care (SOC) as issued by the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (until 2006 called the Harry Benjamin International Gender Dysphoria Association).[34] The SOC are intended as guidelines, not inflexible rules, meant to discourage people from transitioning based on unrealistic expectations.
It is claimed that reviews of post-operative transsexuals prior to 1991 reveal a rate of serious regrets of less than 1% for transsexual men and less than 2% for transsexual women, while studies published after 1991 have reported a decrease in the rates for both, likely due to improved psychological and surgical treatments and increasing acceptance from society.[35] While such studies lend support for existing protocols concerning care of transsexuals, post-operative follow-up research is considered to be lacking. However a note on a report in the UK Guardian Newspaper states:
There is no conclusive evidence that sex change operations improve the lives of transsexuals, with many people remaining severely distressed and even suicidal after the operation, according to a medical review conducted exclusively for Guardian Weekend tomorrow.
A review of more than 100 international medical studies of post-operative transsexuals by the University of Birmingham's aggressive research intelligence facility (Arif) found no robust scientific evidence that gender reassignment surgery is clinically effective.
Against the statistic above indicating that 1% to 2% of post-operative persons have serious regrets, the Report itself states:
Paradoxically, a growing number of post-operative transsexuals are scathing about their medical care. International research suggests that 3-18% of them come to regret switching gender.[37]
Psychological treatment
Psychological techniques that attempt to alter gender identity to one considered appropriate for the person's assigned sex are typically ineffective. The widely-recognized Standards of Care[38] note that sometimes the only reasonable and effective course of treatment for transsexual people is to go through sex reassignment therapy.[39][40]
The need for treatment is emphasized by the high rate of mental health problems, including depression, anxiety, and various addictions, as well as a higher suicide rate among untreated transsexual people than in the general population.[41] These problemsmay be alleviated by a change of gender role and/or physical characteristics.[42]
Many transgender and transsexual activists, and many caregivers, note that these problems usually are not related to the gender identity issues themselves, but the social and cultural responses to gender-variant individuals. Some transsexual people reject the counselling that is recommended by the Standards of Care[43] because they don’t consider their gender identity to be a psychological problem.
Brown and Rounsley[44] noted that "[s]ome transsexual people acquiesce to legal and medical expectations in order to gain rights granted through the medical/psychological hierarchy." Legal needs such as a change of sex on legal documents, and medical needs, such as sex reassignment surgery, are usually difficult to obtain without a doctor and/or therapist's approval. Because of this, some transsexual people feel coerced into affirming outdated concepts of gender to overcome simple legal and medical hurdles (Brown 107).
Medical aspects
After initial psychological counseling, men and women may begin medical treatment starting with hormone replacement therapy[45] or hormone blockers. People who change sex are usually required to live as members of their target sex for at least one year prior to genital surgery (so-called Real-Life Test or Real-Life Experience).[45] Transsexual individuals may undergo some, all, or none of the medical procedures available, depending on personal feelings, health, income, and other considerations. Some people posit that transsexualism is a physical condition, not a psychological issue, and assert that sex reassignment therapy should be given on request. (Brown 103)
Legal and social aspects
Laws regarding changes to the legal status of transsexuals are different from country to country. Some jurisdictions allow an individual to change their name, and sometimes, their legal gender, to reflect their gender identity. Within the US, some states allow amendments or complete replacement of the original birth certificates[46]. Some states seal earlier records against all but court orders in order to protect the transsexual's privacy.
In many places, it is not possible to change birth records or other legal designations of sex, although changes are occurring. Estelle Asmodelle’s book documented her struggle to change the Australian birth certificate and passport laws, although there are other individuals who have been instrumental in changing laws and thus attaining more acceptance for transsexual people in general.
Medical treatment for transsexual and transgender people is available in most Western countries. However, transsexual and transgender people challenge the "normative" gender roles of many cultures and often face considerable hatred and prejudice. The film Boys Don't Cry chronicles the case of Brandon Teena, a transsexual man who was raped and murdered after his status was discovered. The project Remembering Our Dead, founded by Gwendolyn Ann Smith, archives numerous cases of transsexual and transgender people being murdered.[47] In the United States, November 20 has been set aside as the "Day of Remembrance" for all murdered transgender people.[48]
Some people who have switched their gender role enter into traditional social institutions such as marriage and parenting. They sometimes adopt or provide foster care for children, as complete sex reassignment therapy inevitably results in infertility. Some transsexual people have children from before transition. Some of these children continue living with their transitioning/transitioned parent, or retain close contact with them, with no harm to these children in any way.[49]
The style guides of many media outlets prescribe that a journalist who writes about a transsexual person should use the name and pronouns used by that person. Family members and friends, who are often confused about pronoun usage or the definitions of sex, are frequently instructed in proper pronoun usage, either by the transsexual person or by professionals or other persons familiar with pronoun usage as it relates to transsexual people. Sometimes, transsexual people have to correct their friends and family members many times before they begin to use the proper pronouns consistently.
Coming out
Employment issues
Transsexuals can have difficulty maintaining employment. Most find it necessary to remain employed during transition in order to cover the costs of living and transition. However, employment discrimination against transpeople is rampant and many of them are fired when they come out or are involuntarily outed at work.[50] Transsexual people must decide whether to transition on-the-job[51], or to find a new job when they make their social transition. Finding employment can be especially challenging for those in mid-transition.
Laws regarding name and gender changes in many countries make it difficult for transsexual people to conceal their trans status from their employers.[52] Because the Harry Benjamin Standards of Care require a one year RLT prior to SRS, some feel this creates a Catch 22 situation which makes it difficult for transpeople to remain employed or obtain SRS.
In many countries, laws provide protection from workplace discrimination based on gender identity or gender expression, including masculine women and feminine men, whether gay or straight. An increasing number of companies are including "gender identity and expression" in their non-discrimination policies.[53][54] Often these laws and policies don't cover all situations and are not strictly enforced. California's anti-discrimination laws protect transsexual persons in the workplace and specifically prohibits employers from terminating or refusing to hire a person based on their transsexuality. The European Union provides employment protection as part of gender discrimination protections following the European Court of Justice decisions in P v S and Cornwall County Council[55]
Stealth
Transsexual men and women choose to live completely as members of their target gender without being public about their past. This approach is sometimes called stealth, is a personal decision. Some people feel that they have an obligation to be open about their past in order to further the cause of civil rights for LGBT people. Most people recognize that being public about one's transsexual history is a personal choice, and that their medical history is a private matter.
Several examples also exist of people who have been denied medical treatment upon discovery of their trans status, whether it was revealed by the patient or inadvertently discovered by the doctors. For example, Leslie Feinberg was once turned away from a hospital emergency room where he had sought treatment for encephalitis.[56](Feinberg 2) Like Tipton, Feinberg was presenting as a man but had female genital anatomy. He nearly died after being denied treatment. Feinberg's case demonstrates one of the many dangers of actually being discovered. Additionally, Tyra Hunter died after being denied care by paramedics and emergency room physicians after she was injured in an automobile accident.
The equating of "coming out" (whereby a transsexual person who has hidden their true gender identity while maintaining their originally assigned gender role, reveals their true self) with honesty or social activism has been countered by the explanation that, because of prejudice, sensationalism, and the triggering of unconscious personal feelings and emotions, knowledge of someone's transsexual past can prevent the average person from being able to see the transitioned person's true self.
Regrets and detransitions
After transitioning, transsexual people sometimes regret their transition, or even choose to detransition to their original sex. However, every recent study done on the number of detransitions states that their number is well below 1%, and that the reasons for detransitioning are very diverse.[35]
In a 2001 study of 232 MTF patients who underwent GRS with Dr. Toby Meltzer, none of the patients reported complete regret and only 6% reported partial or occasional regrets.[57]
These cases are often cited as reasons for the lengthy triadic process outlined in the Standards of Care, which specifies a treatment process combining psychological, hormonal, and surgical care. While many have criticized this process as being too slow for some, it is argued that without the safeguards within the Standards of Care, the incidence of unsuccessful surgical transitions would be much higher. This is also questioned by many critics, especially with regard to particular demands of some caregivers. The article above states that in some of these cases, transitioning could have been prevented if some demands made by caregivers, or demands perceived as coming from the caregivers, had been less rigid; particularly, if the patients had not felt that talking about any problems or doubts would jeopardize their further treatment. An unwavering demand for medical treatment and the absolute conviction of "doing the right thing" is often seen as a necessity for the diagnosis of transsexualism, and therefore the prerequisite for any further treatment; consequently, further treatment has been denied to people who uttered any doubts or even questions.
Critics claim that when patients cannot talk about problems or doubts, but have to present themselves as having neither, the patients, anxious to get treatment they perceive at this point to be absolutely necessary, will face these problems or doubts after transitioning, when dealing with them may be much more difficult, and this will often lead to social problems, depression, anxiety, or other problems. They believe that, in some cases, this may lead to a retransitioning. While there is no scientific study on the question, many trans*-organizations and groups claim that patients who feel less pressure to conform to any particular stereotype will have more satisfactory outcomes after transition. This does not preclude any screening for mental problems which might lead to pseudo-transsexualism, nor supportive psychological therapy, if necessary.
Additionally, some people detransition after SRS because their desire was to undergo SRS and continue living in the gender role assigned to them at birth.[58] However, they transition temporarily in order to satisfy the requirement of a real-life test.
Depictions of transsexualism in the media
Transsexualism was discussed in the mass media as long ago as the 1930s. The American magazine Time in 1936 devoted an article to what it called "hermaphrodites", treating the subject with sensitivity and not sensationalism [59]. It described the call by Avery Brundage, who led the American team to the 1936 Summer Olympics in Berlin, that a system be established to examine female athletes for "sex ambiguities"; two athletes changed sex after the Games.
Although many transsexual people are modest about their bodies, and are found in all walks of life and professions, transsexual women are commonly featured in pornographic works. When depicted without having undergone vaginoplasty, they are usually referred to as "shemales". While some pre-operative transwomen call themselves and others like them "shemales," the term is regarded as offensive by many transsexual people.[60]
Films depicting transgender issues includeTransamerica The World According to Garp, The Adventures of Priscilla, Queen of the Desert and The Crying Game. The film Different for Girls is notable for its depiction of a transsexual woman who meets up with, and forms a romantic relationship with, her former best friend from her all-male boarding school. Ma Vie en Rose portrays a six-year-old child who is gender variant.
Two notable films depict transphobic violence based on true events: Soldier's Girl (about the relationship between Barry Winchell and Calpernia Addams, and Winchell's subsequent murder) and Boys Don't Cry (about Brandon Teena's murder).
Transsexual people have also been depicted in some popular television shows. In Just Shoot Me!, David Spade's character meets up with his childhood male friend, who has transitioned to living as a woman. After initially being frightened, he eventually forms sexual attraction to his friend, but is scorned, as he is 'not her type'. In an episode of Becker Dr. Becker gets an out-of-town visit from an old friend who turns out to have undergone SRS, it plays out very similar to the situations in Just Shoot Me!. This same thing happens in an episode of Two and a Half Men. In a 1980s episode of The Love Boat, McKenzie Phillips portrays a transwoman who is eventually accepted as a friend by her old high school classmate, series regular Fred Grandy. In the 80's. on "The Jeffersons" one of George's navy buddies 'Eddie' shows up as a woman 'Edie' and is eventually accepted by George.
In the television show, "Ugly Betty", the character Alexis Meade (Portrayed by Rebecca Romijn), formerly Alex Meade, is a post-op transsexual who, before transitioning, faked her own death so she could start her life over as a woman. When Alexis realizes that she can get back at her father (who said he would rather see her dead than as a woman) she comes out of stealth and takes over their business after she tips the authorities off that her father killed Fey Sommers, a character whose death immediately preceded the start of the first series. A serious car accident later leaves Alexis with amnesia, and she forgets the entire previous two years - including her transition from male to female.
The series Law & Order and Nip/Tuck have had transsexual characters, but they were played by non-transsexual women or professional cross-dressers. The series Without a Trace featured an episode in which a transsexual woman went missing and is almost killed by her ex-wife's husband after visiting her family, which she abandoned before transitioning. CSI: Crime Scene Investigation had an episode dealing with a transsexual victim, Ch-Ch-Changes.[61] Many transsexual actresses and extras appeared on the episode, including Marci Bowers and Calpernia Addams.[62] The transwoman victim, Wendy, was played by Sarah Buxton, a cisgender woman. Addams has appeared in numerous movies and television shows, including the 2005 movie Transamerica, in which Felicity Huffman portrays a pre-op transsexual woman.[63]
Recently, Candis Cayne, a transsexual performer, appeared in CSI: NY as a transsexual character. Beginning in the fall 2007 TV season, Candis will also play a transsexual character (this time recurring) in the new ABC series, Dirty Sexy Money.
In fall 2005, the Sundance Channel aired a documentary series known as TransGeneration. This series focused on four transsexual college students, including two transwomen and two transmen, in various stages of transition.[64] In February 2006, LOGO aired Beautiful Daughters, a documentary film about the first all-trans cast of The Vagina Monologues, which included Addams, Lynn Conway, Andrea James, and Leslie Townsend.[65]
Thomas Harris' Silence of the Lambs included a serial killer who considered himself a transsexual. After being turned down for sex reassignment surgery due to not meeting necessary psychological evaluations, he then harvested female bodies to make a feminine suit. In the novel it is noted that the character is not a transsexual; this distinction is made only briefly in the film.[66]
See also
- List of transgender-related topics
- List of transgender-rights organizations
- List of LGBT-related organizations
- List of transgendered people
References
- ^ "ICD-10". Retrieved 2008-09-28.
- ^ American Psychiatric Association (2000). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition (Text Revision). American Psychiatric Publishing. ISBN 0890420254.
- ^ Two-Spirit People: Native American Gender Identity, Sexuality, and Spirituality 1997 U. Illinois, p.100 Sabine Lang et al.
- ^ a b c d e "Gender dysphoria". Retrieved 2008-09-13.
- ^ a b c d e "Diagnostic criteria for Gender Identity Disorder" (PDF). Retrieved 2008-12-21.
- ^ a b c d e Benjamin, H. (1966). The transsexual phenomenon. New York: Julian Press, page 23.
- ^ Schaefer, L.C. and Wheeler, C.C. (1983) The non-surgical true Transsexual: a theoretical rationale. Paper presented at the1983 Harry Benjamin International Gender Dysphoria Association VIII International Symposium, Bordeaux, France.
- ^ a b Gaughan, Sharon (19 August 2006). "What About Non-op Transsexuals? A No-op Notion" (HTML). TS-SI. Retrieved September 30, 2008.
{{cite web}}
: Cite has empty unknown parameter:|coauthors=
(help) - ^ Conway, Lynn (2003), The Strange Saga of Gregory Hemmingway
{{citation}}
: Check|author-link=
value (help); External link in
(help)|author-link=
- ^ Schoenberg, Nara (November 19 2001), "The Son Also Falls From elephant hunter to bejeweled exhibitionist, the tortured life of Gregory Hemingway.", CHICAGO TRIBUNE
{{citation}}
: Check|author-link=
value (help); Check date values in:|date=
(help); External link in
(help)|author-link=
- ^ Miriam Rivera. Excerpt of "There's Something About Miriam". Miriam, a transsexual woman who is open about not having had surgery, talks about how she sees her self, her history, and transsexuality (Television Via Youtube). Filmed in Ibiza, Spain Produced in England.: Edemol & Brighter picture via various Newscorp properties.
{{cite AV media}}
: Unknown parameter|year2=
ignored (help)Clip via youtube. - ^ Female to Male
- ^ BehaveNet - Gender Identity Disorder
- ^ Transexual, transsexual, and restricted Google searches - Language Log
- ^ a b c Pauly MD, Ira B. (28 May 1993). "Terminology and Classification of Gender Identity Disorders". Journal of Psychology & Human Sexuality. 5 (4): 1–12. doi:10.1300/J056v05n04_01. ISSN 0890-7064. Retrieved 2007-02-26.
- ^ Laub, D. R. (1974). "A rehabilitation program for gender dysphoria syndrome by surgical sex change". Plast Reconstr Surg. 53 (4): 388–403. PMID 4592953. Retrieved 2007-02-26.
{{cite journal}}
: Unknown parameter|coauthors=
ignored (|author=
suggested) (help); Unknown parameter|month=
ignored (help) - ^ Fisk, N. (1974). "Gender Dysphoria Syndrome. In D. Laub & P. Gandy (Eds.)". Proceedings of the Second Interdisciplinary Symposium on Gender Dysphoria Syndrome: 7–14.
- ^ Harry Benjamin's Syndrome - definition and aetiology - HBS group
- ^ a b A defining moment in our history - TS Road Map
- ^ Hirschfeld, Magnus; “Die intersexuelle Konstitution” in Jarhbuch fuer sexuelle Zwischenstufen 1923.
- ^ Cauldwell, David Oliver. “Psychopathia Transexualis”, Sexology: Sex Science Magazine vol. 16 (1949),
- ^ Cauldwell, David Oliver. Questions and Answers on the Sex Life and Sexual Problems of Trans-Sexuals: Trans-Sexuals Are Individuals of One Sex and Apparently Psychologically of the Opposite Sex. Trans-Sexuals Include Heterosexuals, Homosexuals, Bisexuals and Others. A Large Element of Transvestites Have Trans-Sexual Leanings. (1950) Haldeman-Julius Big Blue Book B-856.
- ^ Meyerowitz, Joanne Jay; How Sex Changed: A History of Transsexuality in the United States.
- ^ Benjamin, H. “Introduction”, Transsexualism and Sex Reassignment Green, R. and Money, J. (editors, 1969) Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins Press.
- ^ Mukasa, Juliet V. (2006-10-23). Transgender Human Rights Issues in Africa. World International Lesbian and Gay Association (ILGA) PANEL AT 2ND UNCHR SESSION. Retrieved 2006-12-24.
{{cite conference}}
: Check date values in:|date=
(help); Cite has empty unknown parameter:|booktitle=
(help)CS1 maint: location (link) - ^ van Kesteren, Paul J. M (1997). "Mortality and morbidity in transsexual subjects treated with cross-sex hormones". J. Clin. endocrinol. 47 (3). Blackwell, Oxford, UK: 337–343. doi:10.1046/j.1365-2265.1997.2601068.x. PMID 9373456. Retrieved 2007-02-25.
{{cite journal}}
: Unknown parameter|coauthors=
ignored (|author=
suggested) (help) - ^ Olyslager, Femke (2007). "On the Calculation of the Prevalence of Transsexualism" (PDF).
{{cite journal}}
: Cite journal requires|journal=
(help); Unknown parameter|coauthors=
ignored (|author=
suggested) (help) - ^ Reed, Bernard (2008). Presentation on prevalence of transsexual people in the UK.
{{cite conference}}
: Unknown parameter|coauthors=
ignored (|author=
suggested) (help) - ^ Benjamin, H. (1966). The transsexual phenomenon. New York: Julian Press, page 85.
- ^ Brain Study on Transsexuals - BSTc shows biological link
- ^ Male transsexual gene link found BBC News 26 October 2008 (accessed 26 October 2008)
- ^ What can I do about this? Is there hope for me? - transsexual.org
- ^ Becoming a Visible Man p.79, Vanderbilt University Press (May 2004), Jamison Green
- ^ http://wpath.org
- ^ a b Kuiper, A.J (1998). "Gender Role Reversal among Postoperative Transsexuals". International Journal of Transgenderism. 2 (3). Retrieved 2007-02-25.
{{cite journal}}
: Unknown parameter|coauthors=
ignored (|author=
suggested) (help); Unknown parameter|month=
ignored (help) - ^ Sex changes are not effective, say researchers | Society | Society Guardian
- ^ The Guardian Saturday July 31, 2004
- ^ http://wpath.org/publications_standards.cfm
- ^ Endocrine Treatment of Transsexual People: A Review of Treatment Regimens, Outcomes, and Adverse Effects, Eva Moore, Amy Wisniewski and Adrian Dobs
- ^ Standards of Care, WPATH
- ^ Seattle and King County Health - Transgender Health
- ^ The International Transsexual Sisterhood - Study On Transsexuality
- ^ http://wpath.org/publications_standards.cfm
- ^ Brown, Mildred L.; Chloe Ann Rounsley (1996). True Selves: Understanding Transsexualism - For Families, Friends, Coworkers, and Helping Professionals. Jossey-Bass. ISBN 978-0787967024.
- ^ a b "The Harry Benjamin International Gender Dysphoria Association's Standards Of Care For Gender Identity Disorders, Sixth Version February, 2001" (PDF). Retrieved 2008-12-21.
- ^ http://transgenderlaw.org/
- ^ Remembering Our Dead - a memorial to transgender people who have been murdered
- ^ Don't Forget Transgender Day of Rememberance by Jamie Tyroler, January 18, 2008 Kansas City Camp
- ^ Green, MD JD FRCPsych, Richard (1998). "Transsexuals´ Children". International Journal of Transgenderism. 2 (4). Retrieved 2007-02-25.
{{cite journal}}
: Unknown parameter|month=
ignored (help) - ^ Work transition for transsexual women - TS Road Map
- ^ Making a successful transition at work - helpful guide by Jessica McKinnon and sample transition-related documents
- ^ Weiss, Jillian Todd (2001). "The Gender Caste System: Identity, Privacy and Heteronormativity" (PDF). Tulane Law School. Retrieved 2007-02-25.
{{cite journal}}
: Cite journal requires|journal=
(help) - ^ Workplace Discrimination: Gender Identity or Expression - Human Rights Campaign Foundation
- ^ http://transgenderlaw.org/
- ^ Judgment of the Court of 30 April 1996. - P v S and Cornwall County Council. - Reference for a preliminary ruling: Industrial Tribunal, Truro - United Kingdom. - Equal treatment for men and women - Dismissal of a transsexual. - Case C-13/94 - European Court reports 1996 Page I-02143
- ^ Leslie Feinberg, Trans Liberation: Beyond Pink Or Blue pages 2-4; Beacon Press, 1998; ISBN 0807079510
- ^ Factors Associated with Satisfaction or Regret Following Male-to-Female SRS - Anne Lawrence, M.D., Ph. D
- ^ Potential complications of vaginoplasty - TS Road Map
- ^ [1] "Change of Sex" 24 Aug 1936 Time
- ^ What's Offensive - discussion of offensive transsexual terminology
- ^ CSI: Crime Scene Investigation / Ch-Ch-Changes at IMDb
- ^ Calpernia Addams at IMDb
- ^ Transamerica at IMDb
- ^ TransGeneration at IMDb
- ^ Beautiful Daughters - LOGO (TV channel) Documentary
- ^ Silence of the Lambs at IMDb
Bibliography
- Burns, Christine: Why Phrasebook Diversity is not Enough (Press for Change)
- Brown, Mildred L. (1996). True Selves: Understanding Transsexualism - For Families, Friends, Coworkers, and Helping Professionals. Jossey-Bass. ISBN 978-0787967024.
{{cite book}}
: Unknown parameter|coauthors=
ignored (|author=
suggested) (help) - Feinberg, Leslie (1999). Trans Liberation : Beyond Pink or Blue. Beacon Press. ISBN 978-0807079515.
- Standards of Care for Gender Identity Disorders, Sixth Version. - World Professional Association for Transgender Health (2001)
- Kruijver, Frank P. M. (2000). "Male-to-Female Transsexuals Have Female Neuron Numbers in a Limbic Nucleus". Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism. 85 (5): 2034–2041. doi:10.1126. PMID 10843193. Retrieved 2007-02-25.
{{cite journal}}
: Check|doi=
value (help); Unknown parameter|coauthors=
ignored (|author=
suggested) (help); Unknown parameter|doi_brokendate=
ignored (|doi-broken-date=
suggested) (help) - Schneider, Harald J. (2006). "Typical female 2nd-4th finger length (2D:4D) ratios in male-to-female transsexuals-possible implications for prenatal androgen exposure". International Society of Psychoneuroendocrinology. 31 (2). Elsevier, Oxford, UK: 265–269. doi:10.1016/j.psyneuen.2005.07.005. ISSN 0306-4530 PMID 16140461. Retrieved 2007-02-25.
{{cite journal}}
: Unknown parameter|coauthors=
ignored (|author=
suggested) (help) - Xavier, J., Simmons, R. (2000) - The Washington transgender needs assessment survey, Washington, DC: The Administration for HIV and AIDS of the District of Columbia Government
- Rathus, Spencer A. (2002). Human Sexuality in a World of Diversity. Allyn & Bacon. ISBN 978-0205406159.
{{cite book}}
: Unknown parameter|coauthors=
ignored (|author=
suggested) (help) - Denny, Dallas, (2006); Transgender Communities in Transgender Rights.
External links
- Basic TG/TS/IS Information - including Successful Transwomen and Successful Transmen
- FTM International - Female To Male International: practical and medical information
- FTM Australia - Comprehensive information for all men identified female at birth in Australia.
- Hudson's FTM Resource Guide - Comprehensive information for female to male trans men and allies - USA-based
- Gender.org - The home of Gender Education & Advocacy, a nonprofit corporation using the web to provide education and advocacy for transsexual and transgender issues.
- Definition and Synopsis of the Etiology of Adult Gender Identity Disorder and Transsexualism - prepared by 24 internationally recognized experts, published by the Gender Identity Research and Education Society (GIRES)(See: http://www.gires.org.uk)
- How to Respect a Transsexual Person
- The International Journal of Transgenderism - The Official Journal of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (formerly HBIGDA)
- TransParentcy - supports transgender parents and their advocates (lawyers, mental health professionals, friends, family) by providing information and resources.
- Transsexual Road Map - practical and medical information concerning male-to-female transition.