HatchetFaceBuick (talk | contribs) |
HagermanBot (talk | contribs) m HatchetFaceBuick didn't sign: "→genre: " |
||
Line 17: | Line 17: | ||
im not sure where youve heard that.. i dont think they consider themselves grunge or gothic, they simply state there straight edge in interviews. again this is not an opinion we have to put down. we have to state the facts. so what does the band consider them selfs, and not the fans. |
im not sure where youve heard that.. i dont think they consider themselves grunge or gothic, they simply state there straight edge in interviews. again this is not an opinion we have to put down. we have to state the facts. so what does the band consider them selfs, and not the fans. |
||
:trying to figure out what genre bands fit into has become problematic in that people are labeling music according to their look/lifestyle (and the bands'). it is not uncommon anymore (IMO) to hear people say, "i am gothic and i like this band, and other people who are gothic ALSO like this band & the music, therefore, this band must be gothic." the problem is that other people that live other lifestyles might correlate themselves to a band just as well...hence the issue of, "no, 18 Visions is grunge...no, they are hardcore, no...etc." personally, they don't look like the SE kids i am used to...but i like them anyway. =^) |
:trying to figure out what genre bands fit into has become problematic in that people are labeling music according to their look/lifestyle (and the bands'). it is not uncommon anymore (IMO) to hear people say, "i am gothic and i like this band, and other people who are gothic ALSO like this band & the music, therefore, this band must be gothic." the problem is that other people that live other lifestyles might correlate themselves to a band just as well...hence the issue of, "no, 18 Visions is grunge...no, they are hardcore, no...etc." personally, they don't look like the SE kids i am used to...but i like them anyway. =^) <small>—The preceding [[Wikipedia:Sign your posts on talk pages|unsigned]] comment was added by [[User:HatchetFaceBuick|HatchetFaceBuick]] ([[User talk:HatchetFaceBuick|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/HatchetFaceBuick|contribs]]) 16:03, 23 January 2007 (UTC).</small><!-- HagermanBot Auto-Unsigned --> |
Revision as of 16:03, 23 January 2007
Biography: Musicians Unassessed | ||||||||||
|
18v
Is there any way to forward "18V" to this page? --Stonesour025 01:35, 3 August 2006 (UTC)
Just set up the redirector for 18V.
Someone needs to do a better History of this band. After all the changes i made and the albums i did, it seems the history looks too small. Anyone willing to work with me on one? I did the one from As Friends Rust, if you want to check out what ive done.
- I agree, just in looking at their video for "Victim" you can see that most, if not all the members are Straight Edge. That, in and of itself, needs more explanation & detail. --HatchetFaceBuick 22:13, 22 January 2007 (UTC)
genre
to set things straight, let's get their genre fixed. i agree with hard rock, punk rock, hardcore, metalcore etc...but we can also add post-grunge. their music has some serious grunge influence. also gothic rock may be apropriate, since even they refer to themselves as gothic. Itachi1452 01:29, 23 January 2007 (UTC)
im not sure where youve heard that.. i dont think they consider themselves grunge or gothic, they simply state there straight edge in interviews. again this is not an opinion we have to put down. we have to state the facts. so what does the band consider them selfs, and not the fans.
- trying to figure out what genre bands fit into has become problematic in that people are labeling music according to their look/lifestyle (and the bands'). it is not uncommon anymore (IMO) to hear people say, "i am gothic and i like this band, and other people who are gothic ALSO like this band & the music, therefore, this band must be gothic." the problem is that other people that live other lifestyles might correlate themselves to a band just as well...hence the issue of, "no, 18 Visions is grunge...no, they are hardcore, no...etc." personally, they don't look like the SE kids i am used to...but i like them anyway. =^) —The preceding unsigned comment was added by HatchetFaceBuick (talk • contribs) 16:03, 23 January 2007 (UTC).