Comments for
Comments against
Editors must not use sweeping claims or generalisations, and all claims must be supported by referenced sources. Please address one point at a time.
- GoodDay, no one has suggested deleting the Republic of Ireland article. This proposal is not about the RoI Article it's about the Ireland article.
- I'll support this proposal only if the Island, Disambiguation & Country articles are not merged into it or deleted. Do I have an asurance on that? GoodDay (talk) 20:12, 18 June 2009 (UTC)
- This is a proposal, not a bartering house. This proposal involves merging Ireland & Republic of Ireland, under the title Ireland. If you have a suggestion, make one in a new section titles “Suggestions” which I'll consider or propose a solution yourself with a modified version of this. See my comments to Fmph below for an expanded explaination. --Domer48'fenian' 07:55, 19 June 2009 (UTC)
- MickMacNee, you suggested an “Ireland which would cover all conceivable Ireland/Irish topics, such as History, Geography, Politics, Culture etc etc etc. This would include the content from the RoI Article, that's a merger, but this is not your proposal. This is a compilation of a number of proposals by a number of Editors.
- BritishWatcher. Nothing to discuss.
- Rockpocket. All that can be said is provide a Diff for the discussion were there was a consensus that "Ireland is ambiguous." No one can seem to find it. Provide sources to support this opinion per WP:V. Without Diff's there is nothing to discuss.
--Domer48'fenian' 19:41, 18 June 2009 (UTC)
Comments neither for, nor against
- Fmph have a look at the China Article. Notice how it covers subjects in general way in the article, but with each section linking to a more detailed article. That's the idea. Some sections would deal with the whole island for example such as History, Geography, Politics, Culture etc. --Domer48'fenian' 19:51, 18 June 2009 (UTC)
Comments
Editors must not use sweeping claims or generalisations, and all claims must be supported by referenced sources. Please address one point at a time.
Domer, you said "All that can be said is provide a Diff for the discussion were there was a consensus that 'Ireland is ambiguous.'" Which Ireland/Ireland? BastunnutsaB 08:00, 19 June 2009 (UTC)
- Provide a Diff for the discussion were consensus was reached that "Ireland" is ambiguous. Both MASEM & myself can't find it. --Domer48'fenian' 08:15, 19 June 2009 (UTC)
What created the ambiguity was it the wrong naming of Ireland as ROI? BigDuncTalk 11:15, 19 June 2009 (UTC)
- I'm attempting to locate the discussion to determine that see comment above. --Domer48'fenian' 11:20, 19 June 2009 (UTC)