Joe Doe
- Joe Doe (edit | talk | history | protect | delete | links | watch | logs | views)
- (Find sources: Google (books · news · scholar · free images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL)
Fails WP:BIO. Sources in the article aren't enough for notability. A Nominator (talk)
- Keep. I wrote this article. Passes WP:CREATIVE with the reliable sources I used in the article. Voter1 (talk)
- Delete - per nom. Voter2 (talk)
- Delete no evidence of notability. 'nuf said. Voter3 (talk)
- Comment. Did you look at the sources? Voter1 (talk)
- Keep Voter1's links seem to establish notability and pass WP:GNG because they have in-depth information about Doe. Voter4 (talk)
- Delete: Waste of time nominating, should have been speedied A7. Notability just isn't asserted—he's really not that special. Just because his theory was later found to be true doesn't make him notable. Voter5 (talk)
- I respectfully disagree. The theory isn't the point here. It is the significant coverage in reliable sources that justifies this article. Voter4 (talk)
- I respectfully disagree. The theory isn't the point here. It is the significant coverage in reliable sources that justifies this article. Voter4 (talk)
- Strong Delete. seriously? theres no question this stub should be deleted. suggest SNOW closure Voter6 (talk)
- Delete Agree that Doe's simply not notable. He hasn't done anything remarkable IMO, so shouldn't have an article here. Voter7 (talk)
- Keep – The sources meet the gng. Delete voters just aren't willing to admit that it's enough. Voter8 (talk)
- Comment - it looks like the 'keep' voters are relying on the Guardian and Daily Telegraph article, but that simply isn't enough. Voter2 (talk)
Joe Doe
Joe Doe was a scientist best known for developing the Hagea Theory.[1] In 1998, after conducting a series of experiments, Doe came to the realization that _ must be _. His colleagues dismissed his theory as implausible, and Doe acquiesced to their requests not to waste more time trying to verify the theory. Recently, in 2010, scientists have revisited and reevaluated Doe's Hagea Theory, finding that it is indeed an accurate assessment.[2]
- References