where dialogue occurs |
Fred Bauder (talk | contribs) |
||
Line 13: | Line 13: | ||
# |
# |
||
===Too lenient=== |
===Too lenient=== |
||
#The policy is simple and clear, but not applied consistently. [[User:Fred Bauder|Fred]] [[User talk:Fred Bauder|Talk]] 12:11, 29 June 2009 (UTC) |
|||
# |
# |
||
===Too strict=== |
===Too strict=== |
||
# |
# |
Revision as of 12:11, 29 June 2009
Herewith is a poll to gather consensus on how the community feels about the civility policy, in how it is written, applied, and enforced by the community, including the arbitration committee - specifically on how it impacts on the morale and running of the encyclopedia. Furthermore, upon thinking about it, if one were to change aspects of it, what would one change? Please keep comments to a minimum (except in discussion area). Exchanges which veer off the topic will be transferred to the talk page.
Essays which may be of interest (please add others here I may have missed) Casliber (talk · contribs) 06:29, 29 June 2009 (UTC)
- User:FayssalF/Civility pages - a summary
- User:Geogre/Civility
- User:Giano/On civility & Wikipedia in general
- User:Moreschi/Alternative_Civility_Policy
Current civility policy
Please place your view below the appropriate section with respect to how the civility policy, in how it is written, applied, and enforced by the community, including the arbitration committee. if you feel specific sections are problematic, please place new proposals or ideas at the bottom. If too strict or lenient, place a word to indicate where problem is (policy/interpretation/enforcement/other).
Satisfactory
Too lenient
Too strict
Discussion
Should a user's own talk page be considered differently?
There has been discussion in past as to whether a post on a user's talk page, often in reply to a hostile poster, should be treated more leniently than posting elsewhere on other discussion or WP pages where dialogue occurs. Please indicate views below.
Yes, a users' own talk page should be considered more leniently
No, all areas considered equal
Discussion
Myself I am leaning towards this - a userpage may allow people to vent in borderline cases only. Not unequivocal attacks though. Casliber (talk · contribs) 06:33, 29 June 2009 (UTC)