Content deleted Content added
m Reverted 1 edit by Spebi to last revision by Wikihermit; Indeed, however I would like a wider input from the community. using TW |
m →[[Wikipedia:Editor review/Wikihermit 3|Wikihermit]]*: Remove the star as you've been reviewed. If you want me to review, ask on my talk page. |
||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
===[[Wikipedia:Editor review/Wikihermit 3|Wikihermit]] |
===[[Wikipedia:Editor review/Wikihermit 3|Wikihermit]]=== |
||
{{user|Wikihermit}} Hello, I'm Wikihermit. I was wondering what the community thought of my progress since my RfA back in early June. Thanks! <span style="font-family:Trebuchet MS">''<font color="#0A9DC2">''~''</font>''''' [[User_talk:Wikihermit|<font color="#0DC4F2">Wi</font><font color="#3DD0F5">ki</font>]]<font color="#6EDCF7">her</font><font color="#9EE8FA">mit</font>'''</span> 20:12, 3 August 2007 (UTC) |
{{user|Wikihermit}} Hello, I'm Wikihermit. I was wondering what the community thought of my progress since my RfA back in early June. Thanks! <span style="font-family:Trebuchet MS">''<font color="#0A9DC2">''~''</font>''''' [[User_talk:Wikihermit|<font color="#0DC4F2">Wi</font><font color="#3DD0F5">ki</font>]]<font color="#6EDCF7">her</font><font color="#9EE8FA">mit</font>'''</span> 20:12, 3 August 2007 (UTC) |
||
<!--Use {{admin| instead of {{user| if you are a sysop.--> |
<!--Use {{admin| instead of {{user| if you are a sysop.--> |
||
''' Reviews ''' |
|||
''' Reviews '''*<!-- Remove the ASTERISK next to the username and this TAG when you review this user --> {{Not yet reviewed}} |
|||
*Hello, Wikihermit. You are an ''excellent'' editor. I admire your active participation with bots. I also like your participation at AfD, although I would like to see you elaborate on your rationale when nominating articles for deletion. For me, saying "Non-notable person" is not enough. You should say, "Subject fails [[WP:BIO]] because he has not received media coverage and no sources could be found, so the article fails [[WP:V]]", or something like that. I also wish you would be more careful when nominating anything for deletion, as you have made some annoying mistakes (no offense meant), like when you nominated [[User:Politics rule]] for deletion, but I'm willing to forget that, as I'm sure that you have a [[WP:BELLY|belly]] :-) I'm fairly satisfied with your mainspace contributions, but I suggest you become more active on that area. I'm sure that if you continue your great work, you'll breeze through RfA :-) Happy editing! --'''[[User:Boricuaeddie|<font color="Green">Boricua</font>]]''[[User:Boricuaeddie/Puerto Rico|<font color="red">e</font>]]''[[User talk:Boricuaeddie|<font color="Green">ddie</font>]]''' 21:50, 4 August 2007 (UTC) |
*Hello, Wikihermit. You are an ''excellent'' editor. I admire your active participation with bots. I also like your participation at AfD, although I would like to see you elaborate on your rationale when nominating articles for deletion. For me, saying "Non-notable person" is not enough. You should say, "Subject fails [[WP:BIO]] because he has not received media coverage and no sources could be found, so the article fails [[WP:V]]", or something like that. I also wish you would be more careful when nominating anything for deletion, as you have made some annoying mistakes (no offense meant), like when you nominated [[User:Politics rule]] for deletion, but I'm willing to forget that, as I'm sure that you have a [[WP:BELLY|belly]] :-) I'm fairly satisfied with your mainspace contributions, but I suggest you become more active on that area. I'm sure that if you continue your great work, you'll breeze through RfA :-) Happy editing! --'''[[User:Boricuaeddie|<font color="Green">Boricua</font>]]''[[User:Boricuaeddie/Puerto Rico|<font color="red">e</font>]]''[[User talk:Boricuaeddie|<font color="Green">ddie</font>]]''' 21:50, 4 August 2007 (UTC) |
Revision as of 05:08, 7 August 2007
Wikihermit
Wikihermit (talk · contribs) Hello, I'm Wikihermit. I was wondering what the community thought of my progress since my RfA back in early June. Thanks! ~ Wikihermit 20:12, 3 August 2007 (UTC)
Reviews
- Hello, Wikihermit. You are an excellent editor. I admire your active participation with bots. I also like your participation at AfD, although I would like to see you elaborate on your rationale when nominating articles for deletion. For me, saying "Non-notable person" is not enough. You should say, "Subject fails WP:BIO because he has not received media coverage and no sources could be found, so the article fails WP:V", or something like that. I also wish you would be more careful when nominating anything for deletion, as you have made some annoying mistakes (no offense meant), like when you nominated User:Politics rule for deletion, but I'm willing to forget that, as I'm sure that you have a belly :-) I'm fairly satisfied with your mainspace contributions, but I suggest you become more active on that area. I'm sure that if you continue your great work, you'll breeze through RfA :-) Happy editing! --Boricuaeddie 21:50, 4 August 2007 (UTC)
Comments
- View this user's edit count using Interiot's 'Wannabe Kate' Tool.
- View this user's edit summary usage with mathbot's tool
Questions
- Of your contributions to Wikipedia, are there any about which you are particularly pleased, and why?
- Have you been in any conflicts over editing in the past or do you feel other users have caused you stress? How have you dealt with it and how will you deal with it in the future?
- Not really. I had a small dispute when I was new back in April over archiving talk pages, and my RfA was a bummer, but I really haven't had any conflicts.