Line 15: | Line 15: | ||
--> |
--> |
||
====[[Curly Wurly]], [[Nilla Wafers]], [[Pepperidge Farm]], [[Famous Amos]], [[Taxi (candy)]], [[List of Nestlé brands]], [[Arnott's Biscuits Holdings]], [[Passion Pop]], [[Dynamic Images]] [[Whippet cookie]], [[Wagon Wheels (biscuit)]], [[Toll House]], [[Tiny Teddy]], [[Tim Tam]], [[Teddy Grahams]], [[Tagalongs]], [[Taxi (chocolate]], [[Penguin biscuit]], [[Nutter Butter]], [[Milano (cookie)]], [[Image:Teddygrahams.jpg]], [[Image:Tinyteddy.jpg]], [[Nilla]], [[Maryland Cookies]], [[Magic middles]], [[Iced Vovo]], [[Hydrox]], [[HobNob]], [[Hello Panda]], [[Dunk-a-roos]], [[Duberry cookies]], [[Chips Deluxe]], [[Chips Ahoy!]], [[Choco Leibniz]], [[Brussels cookies]], [[Image:Brusselscookies1.jpg]], [[Breakaway (food)]], [[Anna's Swedish Thins]], [[Pirouline]]==== |
====[[Curly Wurly]], [[Nilla Wafers]], [[Pepperidge Farm]], [[Famous Amos]], [[Taxi (candy)]], [[List of Nestlé brands]], [[Arnott's Biscuits Holdings]], [[Passion Pop]], [[Dynamic Images]] [[Whippet cookie]], [[Wagon Wheels (biscuit)]], [[Toll House]], [[Tiny Teddy]], [[Tim Tam]], [[Teddy Grahams]], [[Tagalongs]], [[Taxi (chocolate]], [[Penguin biscuit]], [[Nutter Butter]], [[Milano (cookie)]], [[Image:Teddygrahams.jpg]], [[Image:Tinyteddy.jpg]], [[Nilla]], [[Maryland Cookies]], [[Magic middles]], [[Iced Vovo]], [[Hydrox]], [[HobNob]], [[Hello Panda]], [[Dunk-a-roos]], [[Duberry cookies]], [[Chips Deluxe]], [[Chips Ahoy!]], [[Choco Leibniz]], [[Brussels cookies]], [[Image:Brusselscookies1.jpg]], [[Breakaway (food)]], [[Anna's Swedish Thins]], [[Pirouline]], [[Image:Iced vovos.jpg]], ==== |
||
The above were all speedied by [[User:Improv]] under the new G11 [[WP:CSD|speedy deletion]] criteria. None of these, of course, were actually adverts, but rather articles on highly notable products. They should all be '''overturned and restored'''. Feel free to break this nomination apart if the group nomination is a bad idea, but please don't remove ones that may have been recreated, a definitive answer would be beneficial. --[[User:Badlydrawnjeff|badlydrawnjeff]] <small>[[User_talk:Badlydrawnjeff|talk]]</small> 17:59, 9 October 2006 (UTC) |
The above were all speedied by [[User:Improv]] under the new G11 [[WP:CSD|speedy deletion]] criteria. None of these, of course, were actually adverts, but rather articles on highly notable products. They should all be '''overturned and restored'''. Feel free to break this nomination apart if the group nomination is a bad idea, but please don't remove ones that may have been recreated, a definitive answer would be beneficial. --[[User:Badlydrawnjeff|badlydrawnjeff]] <small>[[User_talk:Badlydrawnjeff|talk]]</small> 17:59, 9 October 2006 (UTC) |
Revision as of 18:11, 9 October 2006
- Full reviews may be found in this page history. For a summary, see Wikipedia:Deletion review/Recently concluded (2006 October)
9 October 2006
Curly Wurly, Nilla Wafers, Pepperidge Farm, Famous Amos, Taxi (candy), List of Nestlé brands, Arnott's Biscuits Holdings, Passion Pop, Dynamic Images Whippet cookie, Wagon Wheels (biscuit), Toll House, Tiny Teddy, Tim Tam, Teddy Grahams, Tagalongs, Taxi (chocolate, Penguin biscuit, Nutter Butter, Milano (cookie), , File:Tinyteddy.jpg, Nilla, Maryland Cookies, Magic middles, Iced Vovo, Hydrox, HobNob, Hello Panda, Dunk-a-roos, Duberry cookies, Chips Deluxe, Chips Ahoy!, Choco Leibniz, Brussels cookies, File:Brusselscookies1.jpg, Breakaway (food), Anna's Swedish Thins, Pirouline, File:Iced vovos.jpg,
The above were all speedied by User:Improv under the new G11 speedy deletion criteria. None of these, of course, were actually adverts, but rather articles on highly notable products. They should all be overturned and restored. Feel free to break this nomination apart if the group nomination is a bad idea, but please don't remove ones that may have been recreated, a definitive answer would be beneficial. --badlydrawnjeff talk 17:59, 9 October 2006 (UTC)
Laura Bennett, Kayne Gillaspie, Uli Herzner
The three above people are all contestants on Project Runway season 3. On August 28, the articles for Bennett and Gillaspie were put on AfD; Bennett's was kept ("vote", inc. nominator, was 10/3- see [1]) and Gillaspie's was a no consensus ("vote" of 7/4 in favor of keep, inc. nominator's "vote"- see [Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kayne Gillaspie]). These discussions were closed on September 6 and September 8, respectively, by two different closers. On October 6, User:Alkivar deleted all three articles, citing failure of WP:BIO. I feel that this is an error, especially for the former two articles (Herzner's article was never AfD'd, but as she is one of the final four competitors on a talent-based reality show, there's obviously some claims to notability). I propose restoring all three, leaving Bennett's and Gillaspie's kept as is, and putting Herzner's on AfD to gather a consensus. -- Kicking222 17:53, 9 October 2006 (UTC)
Quasimoto Interactive
Quasimoto Interactive was marked for speedy deletion, yet met none of the requirements for such deletion. I have messaged the administrator in charge of deletion requesting a review. I've heard nothing back from the 16 year old admin. Please review this decision, and I will make whatever changes need to be made.
Google Sightseeing
Page was deleted on September 30th (I think without an Afd?) but has since been re-rewritten with poorer copy at Google Sightseeing. Original grounds for deletion were failing WP:WEB, however website has been well covered in the press (as detailed on the site's own Press Page) and has a high Alexa rank. Please consider for un-deletion. (Shreddies 15:45, 9 October 2006 (UTC))
X Is Loaded
I have written two articles (the first in pained detail) on the band X Is Loaded (called either X Is Loaded or Xisloaded), user name Miffsey, and have found that they have been deleted for no apparent or given reason - I tried carefully to follow your policy. Could you please review this deletion for me?
Please notify the administrator who performed the action that you wish to be reviewed by leaving ==page name on deletion review== An editor has asked for a deletion review of page name. Since you closed the deletion discussion for (or speedy-deleted) this article, your reasons on how or why you did so will be greatly appreciated in the above review. on their talk page. -->
Z Games
The Z Games article was originally deleted due to Z Games not being considered a "notable company." Z Games is, however, quite a popular company, and their products have been downloaded many thousands of times. Here are some reasons of why Z Games is a notable company:
- Z Games has all of its titles either pending or currently featured on Cnet's Download.com and Windows Marketplace.
- Z Games products have been downloaded over 60,000 times. Here is the Z Games company page on Cnet's Download.com: Z Games on Download.com. Please note that 7 of the games are currently considered popular by Cnet.
- The Z Games downloadable "console", PURGAMENTUM, won 2nd prize in the Game Maker Dev contest, which is held by a popular resource site for users of Game Maker. Here is a posting on http://gamemaker-dev.com that lists the winners of the contest: Game Maker Dev Forums.
- Z Games products are highly popular in certain cities where the company has promoted its games.
- Please check the news section of the official Z Games website, http://zgames.sitesled.com, for a more detailed listing of the history and accomplishments of the Z Games company.
There was also concern that the Z Games article was possibly being used as a means of advertising. I do not believe that the article was promotional, but I am willing to adjust it to make the article meet Wikipedia's standards.
Any problems involving advertisement or notability in the past were probably caused by miscommunication or misunderstanding by me. Please consider un-deleteing the Z Games article, and I will work with you to make the article satisfactory.
Thanks. ZGames