NuclearUmpf (talk | contribs) →Kept: fix |
NuclearUmpf (talk | contribs) →Current XfDs:: removed non-conspiracy based XfD, breaking your own rules after a AfD? doesnt sound smart |
||
(One intermediate revision by one other user not shown) | |||
Line 20: | Line 20: | ||
==Current XfDs:== |
==Current XfDs:== |
||
# |
|||
==Misc. Discussions of interest== |
==Misc. Discussions of interest== |
Revision as of 11:27, 2 January 2007
Introduction, purpose and inclusion criteria
This page is a noticeboard for editors interested in conspiracy-related AfDs. It began life as a tool to help users easily track the flood of 9/11 conspiracy theory AfDs that started around the fifth anniversary of the 9/11 terrorist attacks. These AfDs primarily targetted articles on subjects with little or no notability, which violated WP:NPOV, WP:OR and WP:V and which were created (in my opinion) for the purpose of promoting people, ideas, and books rather than for furthering wikipedia's mission. A great many wikipedians agreed with this assessment and as a result approx. 44 articles were deleted and approx. 8 AfDs did not reach a consensus. Because there is significant interest in tracking AfDs related to other conspiracy theories, I have broadened the page and renamed it GabrielF/ConspiracyNoticeboard. Below I am formally defining the scope of the page based on its past usage and discussion at talk.
What can be included:
- Articles, templates or miscellaneous pages dealing with conspiracy theories and their proponents, provided that the nominator feels that these pages either
- Are Non-notable
- Are Wikipedia:Vanispamcruftisements
- Violate WP:NPOV, WP:NOR or WP:V
- Are so inherently flawed that they cannot be brought up to wikipedia standards
What cannot be included:
- Nominations based purely on the editors dislike of the subject of the article and not on policy
- Articles unrelated to conspiracy theories
Finally, just because an AfD is listed here doesn't mean that I support it.
Note to editors - discuss this on the talk page, not here. When you add or comment on an XfD, please sign your comments. Thanks. GabrielF 02:30, 12 October 2006 (UTC)
Current XfDs:
Misc. Discussions of interest
- None pending
Closed discussions
Deleted
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Big Wedding
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/9/11 Synthetic Terror
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Assassination Science
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bob Mcilvaine
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christian Faith and the Truth Behind 9/11
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crossing the Rubicon (Ruppert)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martial Law: 9/11 Rise of the Police State
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Flocco
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TerrorStorm (2nd Nomination)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniele Ganser
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/America Destroyed By Design
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin Ryan
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Bollyn
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Woodward (psychologist)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/9-11: The Road to Tyranny (3rd nomination)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Genesis_Communications_Network
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jack Blood
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Bermas - hard redirected to Loose Change (video)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Korey Rowe - hard redirected to Loose Change (video)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Louder than Words - hard redirected to Loose Change (video)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dark Secrets: Inside Bohemian Grove
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Controlled-Demolition Theory (9/11 Conspiracy Theory)
- Wikipedia:Templates_for_deletion#Template:Alex_Jones
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Nazi Connection to Islamic Terrorism (book)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dylan Avery
- Wikipedia:Miscellany for deletion/Wikipedia:Association of 9/11 All Sides Editors
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Joseph Watson (second nomination)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Jones' websites
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oklahoma City bombing conspiracy theories
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Controlled_demolition_hypothesis_for_the_collapse_of_the_World_Trade_Center
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Don Paul
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Progressive Press
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Larry Silverstein's Comments On WTC Building 7 Collapse
- Wikipedia:Redirects for discussion/Log/2006 October 6 - Chimpeachment
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kenneth L. Kuttler (second nomination)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Walden Three
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Terror Conspiracy
- Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Mark_Robinowitz
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Christison (CIA)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kathleen Christison
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Post Election Selection Trauma (second nomination)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lori Klausutis (third nomination)
- Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Andy_Stephenson
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Rivero
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cancer conspiracy -- snowball delete
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coincidence theory (second nomination)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gary Caradori
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Final Jihad
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martin Keating
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Franklin Coverup
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Worldwide perception of Osama bin Laden
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rosalee Grable
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Power of Israel in the United States
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Conspiracy of Silence (second nomination)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthony J. Hilder
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Foreign interference with elections in democratic countries
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sofia Åkerberg
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of proven conspiracies (2nd nomination)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Idiotarian
Merged
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/9/11: Debunking The Myths --> Debunking_9/11_Myths
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Thompson (researcher) (2nd Nomination) --> The Terror Timeline
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Evolution of Intelligence --> James Fetzer
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Murder in Dealey Plaza --> James Fetzer
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Great Zapruder Film Hoax --> James Fetzer
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Assassination --> James Fetzer
No Consensus
- Wikipedia:Templates_for_deletion/Log/2006_September_3#Template:911tm (19 deletes vs 7 keeps)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Terror Timeline (16 deletes vs 10 keeps)
- Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/9/11:_Press_for_Truth (19 deletes vs 22 keeps)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/911: In Plane Site (second nomination) (21 keeps vs 21 deletes)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Controlled demolition hypothesis for the collapse of the World Trade Center (I'm not even going to try to count that mess; see Wikipedia_talk:Articles_for_deletion/Controlled_demolition_hypothesis_for_the_collapse_of_the_World_Trade_Center#Closing_rationales for closing admin's rationale)
- Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Webster_G._Tarpley (26 deletes vs 9 keeps)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The War on Freedom - (21 deletes vs 13 keeps)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James W. Walter (second nomination) - (16 keeps vs 16 deletes)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rumours and conspiracy theories about the July 2005 London bombings
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The CIA and September 11 (book)(2nd) - (19 keep - 7 delete)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The New Pearl Harbor - (12 keep - 8 delete)
Kept
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mathias Bröckers
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yellowcake forgery (as moved to Niger uranium documents)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pathological skepticism (as moved to Pseudoskepticism)
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clinton Chronicles
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff Rense (2nd nomination)
- Wikipedia:Miscellany_for_deletion/User:GabrielF/ConspiracyNoticeboard Snowball Keep
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hacking Democracy Snowball Keep
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allegations of state terrorism by United States of America
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moshe Aryeh Friedman
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/9/11: The Big Lie
- Wikipedia:Miscellany for deletion/User:GabrielF/ConspiracyNoticeboard (2nd mfd)
Deletion Review
- Wikipedia:Deletion_review/Log/2006_September_25#9-11: The Road to Tyranny -- deletion endorsed
- Wikipedia:Deletion_review/Log/2006 October 22#Andy Stephenson -- deletion endorsed
- Wikipedia:Deletion review/Log/2006 October_29#Walter Andrew Stephenson -- deletion endorsed
- Wikipedia:Deletion_review/Log/2006_November_4#Terrorstorm - deletion endorsed - see [1] GabrielF 22:01, 9 November 2006 (UTC)