→Unprotected: re:Tony Sidaway |
rm duplicated message |
||
(2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
Line 6: | Line 6: | ||
:I am in all honesty trying to rewrite some sentences to make it as neutral as possible. By for example adding "according to WGKF" in some cases that are disputed by the other side and by adding links with evidence to prove statements, I hope to accomplish this. Anyway, true or not, it doesn't really matter, this whole article is about World Genseiryu Karatedo Federation (WGKF) and therefore about the '''viewpoint''' of the WGKF, the federation that trains the traditional Genseiryu as taught by sensei Seiken Shukumine and follows his first book ''"Shin Karatedo Kyohan"''. This viewpoint should NOT be changed into the viewpoint of those following sensei Tosa. Their story is different and is the viewpoint of [[Genseiryu Karatedo International Federation]]. Although WGKF does not acknowledge that story, nobody of WGKF ever changed that article. Some people of GKIF (actually just one who is now using dynamic ip) have been changing this article here (WGKF) into the viewpoint of GKIF. Then the story is not anymore about WGKF but about GKIF and there is already an article about that! They should change that article, not this one, if they want to keep an honest and neutral environment on Wikipedia. Regards, [[User:Mario Roering|Mario<font color="green">''R''</font>]] 22:37, 11 August 2005 (UTC) |
:I am in all honesty trying to rewrite some sentences to make it as neutral as possible. By for example adding "according to WGKF" in some cases that are disputed by the other side and by adding links with evidence to prove statements, I hope to accomplish this. Anyway, true or not, it doesn't really matter, this whole article is about World Genseiryu Karatedo Federation (WGKF) and therefore about the '''viewpoint''' of the WGKF, the federation that trains the traditional Genseiryu as taught by sensei Seiken Shukumine and follows his first book ''"Shin Karatedo Kyohan"''. This viewpoint should NOT be changed into the viewpoint of those following sensei Tosa. Their story is different and is the viewpoint of [[Genseiryu Karatedo International Federation]]. Although WGKF does not acknowledge that story, nobody of WGKF ever changed that article. Some people of GKIF (actually just one who is now using dynamic ip) have been changing this article here (WGKF) into the viewpoint of GKIF. Then the story is not anymore about WGKF but about GKIF and there is already an article about that! They should change that article, not this one, if they want to keep an honest and neutral environment on Wikipedia. Regards, [[User:Mario Roering|Mario<font color="green">''R''</font>]] 22:37, 11 August 2005 (UTC) |
||
== Edit summaries == |
|||
At least several of the edit summaries to these articles have been of an inflammatory nature. Edit summaries are for summarizing your edit not for attacking, criticising or disagreeing with anyone. Please confine your discussions to talk pages and be [[WP:CIVIL]]. I am going to warn you both openly that, if you continue using such edit summaries, you will surely be blocked, although the anonymous IP user should take particular note. I would urge you to look for other areas of Wikipedia to contribute to as well, where you may find less conflict. -[[User:Splash|Splash]] 22:30, 14 August 2005 (UTC) |
Revision as of 21:57, 15 August 2005
Regarding the Neutral Point of View of the article
Please, write only facts, in a NEUTRAL way, not opions. Write in an encyclopedic way.
To prevent a new edit war: People of GKIF are kindly requested to write any contradicting information in the article about GKIF. People from WGKF are requested not to touch that article and people from GKIF are requested not to touch this article about WGKF to prevent another EDIT WAR and keep the whole story as neutral and honest as possible. Also a link to the main article Genseiryu should be kept in both articles at all times, since they are a continuation of that article... Thank you for your co-operation! -- MarioR 21:44, 24 July 2005 (UTC)
Unprotected
It's about nearly two weeks, that's long enough. I don't want to see a repetition of edit warring, I'll be watching and will deal with serious disruption as I judge necessary. --Tony SidawayTalk 18:06, 10 August 2005 (UTC)
- I am in all honesty trying to rewrite some sentences to make it as neutral as possible. By for example adding "according to WGKF" in some cases that are disputed by the other side and by adding links with evidence to prove statements, I hope to accomplish this. Anyway, true or not, it doesn't really matter, this whole article is about World Genseiryu Karatedo Federation (WGKF) and therefore about the viewpoint of the WGKF, the federation that trains the traditional Genseiryu as taught by sensei Seiken Shukumine and follows his first book "Shin Karatedo Kyohan". This viewpoint should NOT be changed into the viewpoint of those following sensei Tosa. Their story is different and is the viewpoint of Genseiryu Karatedo International Federation. Although WGKF does not acknowledge that story, nobody of WGKF ever changed that article. Some people of GKIF (actually just one who is now using dynamic ip) have been changing this article here (WGKF) into the viewpoint of GKIF. Then the story is not anymore about WGKF but about GKIF and there is already an article about that! They should change that article, not this one, if they want to keep an honest and neutral environment on Wikipedia. Regards, MarioR 22:37, 11 August 2005 (UTC)
Edit summaries
At least several of the edit summaries to these articles have been of an inflammatory nature. Edit summaries are for summarizing your edit not for attacking, criticising or disagreeing with anyone. Please confine your discussions to talk pages and be WP:CIVIL. I am going to warn you both openly that, if you continue using such edit summaries, you will surely be blocked, although the anonymous IP user should take particular note. I would urge you to look for other areas of Wikipedia to contribute to as well, where you may find less conflict. -Splash 22:30, 14 August 2005 (UTC)