temp, pending consensus |
Undid revision 587679457 by Lihaas (talk) testing f |
||
Line 38: | Line 38: | ||
}} |
}} |
||
On the evening of 14 December 2013, a faction of the [[Sudan People's Liberation Army]] caused a political crisis, beginning as a [[mutiny]], in [[South Sudan]]. [[President of South Sudan|President]] [[Salva Kiir]] announced that the coup attempt was put down the next day, but fighting resumed on 16 December and spread beyond the capital, [[Juba]], to the region around [[Jonglei]] which is prone to ethnic instability<!--background mentions fighting there is regular-->, again largely along ethnic lines. At least 500–1,000 people were reported to have been killed and over 800 other people were injured.<ref name="gunfire">{{cite web|url=http://worldnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2013/12/21/21996598-four-hurt-as-gunfire-hits-us-military-plane-sent-to-evacuate-americans-from-south-sudan?lite |title=Four hurt as gunfire hits US military plane sent to evacuate Americans from South Sudan |publisher=Worldnews.nbcnews.com |date= |accessdate=2013-12-24}}</ref><ref name="aljazeera1"/> Kiir blamed former vice president [[Riek Machar]] for instigating the "coup" but Machar denied any knowledge of it and instead blamed Kiir for playing [[power politics]]. [[Bor, South Sudan|Bor]] was seized by the [[South Sudan Liberation Army]] on 19 December. On the same day, a UN compound was stormed in [[Akobo, South Sudan|Akobo]], Jonglei, resulting in two Indian [[UNMISS]] peacekeepers killed.<ref name="akobo">http://allafrica.com/stories/201312220007.html</ref> |
On the evening of 14 December 2013, a faction of the [[Sudan People's Liberation Army]] caused a political crisis, beginning as a [[mutiny]], in [[South Sudan]]. [[President of South Sudan|President]] [[Salva Kiir]] announced that the coup attempt was put down the next day, but fighting resumed on 16 December and spread beyond the capital, [[Juba]], to the region around [[Jonglei]] which is prone to ethnic instability<!--background mentions fighting there is regular-->, again largely along ethnic lines. At least 500–1,000 people were reported to have been killed and over 800 other people were injured.<ref name="gunfire">{{cite web|url=http://worldnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2013/12/21/21996598-four-hurt-as-gunfire-hits-us-military-plane-sent-to-evacuate-americans-from-south-sudan?lite |title=Four hurt as gunfire hits US military plane sent to evacuate Americans from South Sudan |publisher=Worldnews.nbcnews.com |date= |accessdate=2013-12-24}}</ref><ref name="aljazeera1"/> Kiir blamed former vice president [[Riek Machar]] for instigating the "coup" but Machar denied any knowledge of it and instead blamed Kiir for playing [[power politics]]. [[Bor, South Sudan|Bor]] was seized by the [[South Sudan Liberation Army]] on 19 December. On the same day, a UN compound was stormed in [[Akobo, South Sudan|Akobo]], Jonglei, resulting in two Indian [[UNMISS]] peacekeepers killed.<ref name="akobo">http://allafrica.com/stories/201312220007.html</ref> |
||
Though the international [[news media]] have depicted the event mainly as an [[ethnic conflict]] between the [[Dinka]] and [[Nuer people|Nuer]],{{citation needed|date=December 2013}} there are also Dinkas and [[Shilluk people|Shilluk]] on the side of the Nuer rebels such as [[Rebecca Nyandeng De Mabior|Rebecca Garang]], the widow of the [[Sudan People's Liberation Movement|SPLM]] leader [[John Garang]], and [[Pagan Amum]], respectively; while there are [[Equatoria]]ns on the government Dinka-majority side.{{citation needed|date=December 2013}} |
|||
==Background== |
==Background== |
Revision as of 23:45, 25 December 2013
2013 South Sudanese political crisis | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Part of the South Sudan internal conflict (2011–present)[dubious – discuss] | |||||||
![]() Map of South Sudan | |||||||
| |||||||
Belligerents | |||||||
|
![]() (Mostly ethnic Nuers) ![]() | ||||||
Commanders and leaders | |||||||
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() | ||||||
Casualties and losses | |||||||
At least 500 killed*[5] (most of them combatants),[9] 800 injured**,[10] 81,000 IDPs (according to the UN)[11] | |||||||
On the evening of 14 December 2013, a faction of the Sudan People's Liberation Army caused a political crisis, beginning as a mutiny, in South Sudan. President Salva Kiir announced that the coup attempt was put down the next day, but fighting resumed on 16 December and spread beyond the capital, Juba, to the region around Jonglei which is prone to ethnic instability, again largely along ethnic lines. At least 500–1,000 people were reported to have been killed and over 800 other people were injured.[15][5] Kiir blamed former vice president Riek Machar for instigating the "coup" but Machar denied any knowledge of it and instead blamed Kiir for playing power politics. Bor was seized by the South Sudan Liberation Army on 19 December. On the same day, a UN compound was stormed in Akobo, Jonglei, resulting in two Indian UNMISS peacekeepers killed.[16]
Though the international news media have depicted the event mainly as an ethnic conflict between the Dinka and Nuer,[citation needed] there are also Dinkas and Shilluk on the side of the Nuer rebels such as Rebecca Garang, the widow of the SPLM leader John Garang, and Pagan Amum, respectively; while there are Equatorians on the government Dinka-majority side.[citation needed]
Background
Following the independence of South Sudan, Culture Minister Jok Madut Jok said of the country's challenges:[17]
The first leg for any government is a disciplined military. We have problems with the way our military functions today. That's a broken leg. We have civil society, right now it is very weak. The third leg is delivery of services. It is hard to deliver security...The fourth leg is political unity. We had political unity in the days leading up to the referendum [which led to independence]. Since the referendum, we have been having difficulties uniting our ranks. So right now the animal is standing on four crooked legs. If we do not fix these legs, the future is going to be very, very difficult..
The transitional constitution of South Sudan also has broad powers reserved for the president, including sacking governors and appointing MPs. In February, President Salva Kiir ordered more than 100 army generals to retire so as to reorganise the military, but this was viewed as troublesome in regards to a power grab by others.[17] Kiir had also suggested that his rivals were trying to revive the rifts that had provoked infighting in the 1990s.[18]
In summer 2011, Riek Machar, who was vice president of the only party, SPLM, was made the vice president of the country. In July 2013, he, along with the entire cabinet, was dismissed from office by Kiir. However, Machar said that Kiir's move was a step towards dictatorship and that he would challenge Kiir for the presidency in the next presidential election scheduled for 2015.[19] He added that if the country is to be united, it cannot tolerate "one man's rule."[20] Kiir also dissolved some key party institutions,[which?] suspended the SPLM Secretary-General Pagan Amum, an ethnic Shilluk, and issued a decree preventing him from leaving Juba or speaking to the media.[21] At the same time, the U.S. and the E.U. feared political upheaval.[22]
Further, Machar and Kiir, while being members of the SPLM, are members of different tribes. Kiir is an ethnic Dinka, while Machar is an ethnic Nuer.[20] Yet it was further pointed out that framing the conflict in ethno-tribal terms was false. The comparison was drawn to the pre-independence war as being framed as one between Christian and Muslim or African and Arab, yet the simply different ethnic frameworks are used today. Statism as used for power basis was also suggested as a cause of the conflict.[23]
Similarly though, since independence, tribal factionalism has routinely occurred, especially in Jonglei.[22] Similarly, United Nations Mission in South Sudan (UNMISS) has had previous conflicts during its mission, particularly in Jonglei.
Initial mutiny
The South Sudanese Sudan Tribune reported clashes breaking out in the Munuki neighbourhood[24] late on 14 December in South Sudan's capital, Juba, between members of the presidential guard.[20] Kiir also claimed that the fighting began when unidentified uniformed personnel started shooting at a meeting of the SPLM.[25][17] Former Minister of Higher Education Peter Adwok said that on the evening 15 December after the meeting of the National Liberation Council had failed, Kiir told Major General Marial Ciennoung to disarm his soldiers of the "Tiger Battalion," which he did. Adwok then controversially claims that the officer in charge of the weapons stores, opened them and rearmed only the Dinka soldiers. A Nuer soldier passing by questioned this and a fistfight then ensued between the two and attracted the attention of the "commander and his deputy to the scene." Unable to calm the situation, more soldiers got involved and raided the stores. It culminated in the Nuer soldiers taking control of the military headquarters. The next morning, he says that SPLA reinforcements arrived and dislodged the mutineers. He then explained standard procedure:
Military doctrine dictates that once a contingent of mutinous troops have been dislodged, appeal is made for their surrender and then disarmed. Those who remained loyal (to the president) are also disarmed to prevent bad blood. The loyal troops of Tiger, hailing mainly from Warrap and Aweil, have not been disarmed. In fact, they are the ones rampaging Juba, looting and shooting to kill any Nuer in the residential neighbourhoods."
Adwok was then placed on a list of wanted politicians, to which he said "this may be my last contribution, because, as I said, I'm waiting for the police in order to join my colleagues in detention."[26]
The military headquarters near Juba University was then attacked with fighting continuing throughout the night.[22] The next day heavy gunfire occurred as the rival factions clashed[20] and heavily-armed soldiers were reportedly on the streets. The UNMISS also reported the sound of mortar and heavy machine-gun fire, while it claimed hundreds of civilians sought refuge inside its facilities[22] Military spokesman Colonel Philip Aguer said that some military installations had been attacked by armed soldiers but that "the army is in full control of Juba." He added that an investigation was under way and that though the situation was tense, it was also unlikely to deteriorate.[20] Several people were also injured during the fighting.[25] Juba International Airport was closed indefinitely, according to unnamed civil aviation and airline sources;[27] Kenyan airlines Fly540 and Kenya Airways indefinitely suspended flights to Juba after the airport closed.[28] A curfew was imposed that would occur every night from 18:00 to 6:00[25] until further notice. State-owned SSTV went off-air for several hours. When it returned to broadcasting, it aired a message by President Salva Kiir.[25] The dissident group was said to include Sudan People's Liberation Movement (SPLM) founder John Garang's widow, Rebecca Garang.[27]
Foreign Minister Barnaba Marial Benjamin said that soldiers at the army base attempted to raid a weapons store but were repulsed. He added that unnamed politicians had also been arrested, but could not confirm if Machar was one of them. He also said that those that were a part of the coup were "disgruntled" soldiers and politicians led by Machar.[22] At least ten people were confirmed to have been detained, including former Finance Minister Kosti Manibe. Five others were sought for questioning, including Machar and Pagan Amum. Information Minister Micheal Makuei Leuth claimed that Machar had left Juba with some soldiers and stolen cattle.[29] Of those arrested, seven were confirmed as former ministers. Other arrests included those of Kiir's critics.[21] Amum then said on 15 December that "I am fine, that's all I can say," while Machar's spokesman, James Gatdet Dak, said Machar "has not been arrested. He's in Juba. He's fine, very fine."[21] However, it was later reported that Amum was being held by the state security apparatus.[30]
Renewed fighting
Despite government claims of having quashed the coup, fighting renewed on 17 December with the Sudan Tribune reporting it had spread to Bor, in Jonglei, where three people had died;[31] this was confirmed by the UN who reported that over 1,000 people sought refuge in its compound there.[18] Fighting started again at 9:00 from a military headquarters[32] and another military barrack, according to Hussein Maar, deputy governor of Jonglei.[33] Fighting also occurred near the presidential palace and other areas of Juba. Ajak Bullen, a doctor at a military hospital, said that "so far, we have lost seven soldiers who died while they were waiting for medical attention and a further 59 who were killed outside. They are there at the mortuary and we are arranging for a mass burial." The Juba Teaching Hospital had previously confirmed 26 deaths – the same number as the government – but there was no confirmation of overlap or which side the dead soldiers were fighting for,[29] according to Makur Matur Kariom, a doctor and Health Ministry official,[32] and Under-Secretary for Health Makur Korion.[19] Hospital director Ajak Bullen said that 400 people were being treated. The International Crisis Group (ICG) reported that fighting occurred between the Dinka and Nuer in Pibor in Jonglei amid reports of ethnically targeted killings. It also reported that Machar's house had been bombarded and "surrounded, including with tanks", while "parts of Juba have been reduced to rubble" and that fighting between Nuer and Dinka had taken place at military barracks in Jonglei.[21] Communication links were either down or poor.[34] The local Radio Tamazuj suggested UNMISS were absent from the streets in Juba during the early fighting and that December 2013's president of the UN Security Council, France's Gérard Araud, had announced that the UN's peacekeepers would not intervene in the fighting.[30] Amongst NGOs, Emma Jane Drew, the acting director of Oxfam's South Sudan office, said in he first days of the conflict that her team were unable to leave their compound in Juba because of "continued shooting."[29]
Fighting between military factions later spread beyond Juba to Jonglei, amid fears of a wider conflict. Military spokesman Colonel Philip Aguer said that there was overnight fighting among troops in Jonglei on 17-18 December and that he was verifying reports of desertions from the military. This followed reports from the ICG that Nuer in the area were defecting from the armed forces and that the Dinka people feared a repeat of the 1991 massacre by the Nuers. Meanwhile, in Juba, a semblance of calm had returned by 18 December with a trickle of traffic.[18] The UN reported that 13,000 people were taking refuge from the fighting in its two compounds in Juba.[29][21]
Fall of Bor and Bentiu
On 19 December, a Nuer militia headed by Peter Gadet, the defected former 8th Division commander, claimed control of Bor, while Aguer said: "Our soldiers have lost control of Bor to the force of Riek Machar late on Wednesday. There was shooting last night. We don't have information on casualties or the displaced in the town, as operations are ongoing." It came a day after Kiir said he was willing to have talks with Machar but that "I do not know what the results of the talks will be."[35] Ethnically targetted violence was also reported.[36] UN deputy spokesman Farhan Haq said that Nuer fighters then stormed one of its compounds in Akobo, Jonglei in pursuit of civilians who had sought refuge there. He suggested there may have been casualties but he could not confirm if there were any victims. He also added that though Juba appears to have become calm there were unconfirmed reports of several students killed by security personal at Juba University on 18 December. He further highlighted the thousands of people who had sought refuge within the UN's compounds and had called for UN protection.[37] The Indian Ambassador to South Sudan Asoke Mukerji had originally said that three Indian peacekeepers were killed but UNMISS later said that one of them was only injured and then evacuated to a UN medical facility in Malakal.[12] The attack had also resulted in loss of contact with the base while Haq said the fate of over 30 ethnic Dinka civilians at the base was not known. In response to the incident UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon issued a statement that read he was "appalled" to learn of the incident and that "there are indications that civilians may have been killed and wounded in the attack, but this remains to be verified. Should these reports prove true, those responsible must be held accountable for their crimes."[38]
At the same time, about 200 employees of the regional petroleum operators, of which the three largest were China National Petroleum Corp, ONGC Videsh and Petronas, sought refuge at an UN compound in Bentiu, Unity. UNMISS spokesman Joe Contreras said: "We expect their presence to be temporary because we understand that the company they are working for will be arranging for transport to get out of Unity State." Leuth said that the petroleum producing areas have not been affected by the conflict.[39] This followed the deaths of 16 such workers, five workers at a field in Unity on 18 December and another 11 at the Thar Jath field the next day. Government soldiers then took control of the fields and said that production continued normally. Unity Governor Mabek Lang De Mading said on 18 December: "We have sent reinforcements to Unity yesterday night and they contained the situation. This morning fighting broke out in Thar Jath. We have sent reinforcements and they have now contained the situation. It is stable now."[40] The rebels had reportedly taken over at least some of the country's oil fields amidst fears of Sudan intervening in the country.[4] Up to 250 men were also rounded up by Dinka gunmen and taken to a Juba police station where they were executed over a two-day period leaving only 12 survivors.[41]
Following calls from the government of South Sudan, Ugandan soldiers were deployed in Juba, according to state-owned New Vision. The first soldiers in the country assisted in securing the airport and evacuating Ugandan citizens[42] On 21 December, four United States troops were injured when gunfire hit three U.S. aircraft[43][44] that were on their way to Bor to evacuate U.S. citizens, one of which was heavily damaged and of the wounded was reportedly in critical condition. South Sudan blamed the rebels for the incident. The aircraft then headed back towards Kampala, Uganda, from where the wounded personnel were flown on to Nairobi, Kenya for medical treatment.[45] Machar asserted that a military government was put in place in Unity.[5] On 22 December, Machar told Al Jazeera that "his" troops were in control of Bentiu.[5]
In Bentiu, Unity on 22 December, General James Koang Chuol, the defected commander of the 4th Division, overthrew Unity's governor and announced the formation of a new administration in the state. He issued a statement over the radio that urged people to return to work and remain calm.[46] While the government admitted it had not writ there and blamed a commander loyal to Machar for having control, the latter denied this. The same day, a full scale tank battle erupted between defected and loyalist tanks in Upper Nile.[8] The same day, and following the failed evacuation by the U.S. military, 15 U.S. citizens, Sudanese-Americans and those working in humanitarian operations, were evacuated by two helicopters - one from the UN and one a civilian contractor - from the United Nations compound in Bor, which was surrounded by 2,000 armed youths but that a local commander had given his assurances of allowing the evacuation. The evacuees were then flown out to Nairobi. In total, 380 officials and private citizens were evacuates, as well as about 300 foreign citizens.[47] At the same time, U.S. and Nigerian envoys were on their way to Juba to try and negotiate a solution.[5]
Escalation
In an escalation of the conflict, Aguer said on 23 December that "the army is on its way to Jonglei and Unity to retake territory and will attack within a few hours."[48] This followed the U.S. envoy to the country, Donald Booth, saying that having spoken to Kiir, the latter was committed to talks with Machar without preconditions.[49] The United States military also announced a repositioning of its forces in Africa to prepare for possible further evacuations as the United Nations warned of the planned strikes.[48] At the same time, despite the offer of talks, South Sudan Information Minister Michael Makuei said that "there is no way we will release anybody who is accused of a coup d'état," and he dismissed claims by Machar that rebels had taken over all the major oil fields in Unity and Upper Nile as merely "wishful thinking." It came after Machar said he has spoken to U.S. National Security Adviser Susan Rice and U.N. envoy Hilde Johnson about resolving the conflict. "My message was let Salva Kiir release my comrades who are under detention and let them be evacuated to Addis Ababa and we can start dialogue straightaway, because these are the people who would (handle) dialogue." His list of detainees to be released included Pagan Amum and Rebecca Garang, who Makeui said of: "They are criminals who must be brought to the books, so there is no way we can negotiate with (Machar)." Meanwhile, UNMISS spokesman, Joe Contreras, added: "For those elements who are trying to intimidate us or who have attacked us, the message is loud and clear: we are here to serve the people of South Sudan and we are not leaving the country under any circumstances."[7] Machar told Radio France Internationale that the rebel side was ready for talks that could possibly occur in Ethiopia and that he had also spoken to U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry and Ethiopian Foreign Minster Tedros Adhanom. "We want democratic free and fair elections. We want Salva Kiir to call it a day."[50] He added that: "The SPLM is the ruling party and the SPLA is the national army and I believe these two organisations can end the term of President Kiir. President Kiir has failed to unite the people. He is inciting inter-ethnic fighting. Now he is dividing the country. So it is best he leaves, and I believe the SPLA and SPLM can make him leave."[51]
On 24 December, the government of South Sudan then claimed to have re-taken control of Bor,[3] according to Kiir. Aguer said that the army was seven miles outside Bor and would soon advance on the city, while "the other cities will be retaken within 72 hours." He also said that the reports of mass graves would be investigated. There was also tension at the UN compound in the city as armed fighters had entered it and about 17,000 civilians seeking protection were at the location.[52] The day's fighting started at 14:00 and lasted largely for two hours. The first parts of town that were re-captured, were where the original fighting started at the Pan-pandiar army headquarters and Malual-chaat village, just outside Bor. The claim of victory came at 19:30. Though most of Gadet's troops had left their position, fighting continued around the airport.[53] On the same day, the SSLA had also entered the town of Malakal[54] Non-military fighters were still reported to be on the streets of Juba's Munuki neighbourhood armed with machetes and knives, while there were also soldiers. Atrocities continue almost daily with reports of ethnic targeting reminiscent of the Second Sudanese Civil War days. It also comes as hundreds of foreign oil company employees gathered at airport to leave two days before.[24] Five Ugandan and ten Kenyan citizens were also evacuated from Bor and then Juba before leaving the country. The Kenyan government said that they were 30,000 of its nationals in the country and that 10,000 had applied for emergency documents; while they said the priority was to evacuate women and children and that it was getting aid to the country as best as it could despite claims of being too slow.[55]
On 25 December, fighting continued in Malakal, according to Ateny, who added that the "oil fields are safe."[56] Makwei said that though "there is fighting now in Malakal since morning between the government forces and the rebels. It is not true that the rebels have taken over." Five of the 10 regions[which?] of South Sudan had reported fighting, including the aforementioned Central Equatoria, Jonglei, Unity and Upper Nile.[57] The UN also reported that renewed fighting and deteriorating conditions in Jonglei occurred south of Bor and that their base was being reinforced with additional protective barriers, including the area hosting the displaced civilians.[11]
Casualties
During the first two days of fighting, reports indicated that 66 soldiers had been killed in clashes in Juba,[58] but that number was complemented by between 400 and 500 people, mostly soldiers, according to a government official[9] and UN diplomats quoting sources in Juba,[59] and at least 800 injured.[15] Almost 250 men were executed by Dinka gunmen.[41] Two Indian UN peacekeepers were killed on 18 December when their base was stormed by rebels, and three US military Osprey aircraft were fired upon leading to four American service personnel being wounded.[60]
On 23 December, the UN's humanitarian coordinator stated the number of dead had likely surpassed 1,000 people[5] while an aid worker in the country estimated that the death toll was most likely in the tens of thousands.[8] On 24 December, the UN's Navi Pillay claimed that the bodies of 75 government soldiers were discovered in a mass grave in Bentiu, while another two mass graves were reportedly found in Juba.[61] The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees's Ravina Shamdasani said an unnamed official had seen over 30 bodies in the two mass graves and its existence was being verified. "It is very difficult, and there are reports that some bodies may have already been burned."[62] On 25 December, UNMISS denied the report of a mass grave that was issued by UNHCR. At the same time, Pillay's office revised down the figure of dead bodies to 34 bodies and 75 people were feared missing.[63]
Response
President Salva Kiir spoke on national television on 16 December, having abandoned his traditional suit and cowboy hat for military fatigues, and said, while surrounded by government officials, that the coup had been foiled and that it was orchestrated by
a group of soldiers allied with the former vice president. The attackers went and (the) armed forces are pursuing them. I promise you today that justice will prevail.
Your government led by the SPLM has articulated the ideals of democracy in the party as well as in the government, and I will never deviate from them at any cost. The SPLM is fully committed to the peaceful and democratic transfer of power, and will never allow political power to be transferred through violence.[17]
He further noted that the government was then "in full control of the military situation" and that he had ordered a dawn-to-dusk curfew in Juba.[22] He finally added that "I will not allow or tolerate such incidents once again in our new nation. I strongly condemn these criminal actions in the strongest terms possible. [Those responsible for the incidents would have to stand] before the appropriate law institution."[25] On 21 December, the government wrote on Twitter that "we are ready to dialogue with any rebel group including Dr. Riek Machar without any conditions."[64] Kiir spoke in a Christmas message that "innocent people have been wantonly killed. There are now people who are targeting others because of their tribal affiliation...It will only lead to one thing and that is to turn this new nation into chaos."[65]
Machar spoke for the first time since the crisis began on 18 December in which he said he was not aware of any coup attempt, but instead blamed Kiir for fabricating such allegations of a coup in order to settle political scores and target political opponents. He also said the violence was started by the presidential guard, which was founded by Kiir and told to report directly to him instead of the military.[18] He added: "My bodyguards at the vice presidential residence were summarily executed. They attacked it with tank shells and then burned. It is rubble now. They fired on my residence and I fled.[36] My life was in danger; my colleagues were being arrested for no reason. They are not plotters, it was not a coup. Nobody wants that," instead he said he was "used as a scapegoat" by Kiir to purge the SPLM of his rivals to avoid reforming it[35] and that "the violence is turning tribal and they are killing people in Juba," while people in Jonglei were rising up and taking on the majority Dinka. "Some really heart-wrenching acts have already occurred where Nuer soldiers have been attacked and killed, Nuer government officials, even those serving in the offices of Nuer ministers, and ordinary citizens suspected of having participated in the fight against the government. [At Nairobi Jomo Kenyatta airport, those who have fled speak of] door-to-door executions of Nuer. [Kiir is] inciting ethnic killings and tribal divisions, [he is no longer South Sudan's] legitimate leader. [He] is covering for his inefficiency in running the government and the army." He refused to deny or acknowledge support for Gadet but that "the rebels are acting in the right direction." On 22 December, Machar said he wanted to be the leader of the country and that "his" forces would maintain control of the country's oil fields.[5]
Chief Whip and MP from Eastern Equatoria Tulio Odongi Ayahu called for dialogue and warned that the Equatoria region would not be a participant in the conflict after holding talks with Vice President James Wani Igga. "We Equatorians will promote dialogue. We will not accept undemocratic methods to come into power. At present there is a leader in place. And this leader will have to complete his term of office. Those who may be thinking to take over power by means of violence will not be accepted by the Equatorians. [The opposition is making] premature challenges towards the elected president" and should have used the SPLM party convention and congresses in 2014 instead of "circumvent[ing] the procedure."[66]
Jok Madut Jok wrote: "If the SPLA engages Gadet and possibly Riek and Taban, then we have an all-out civil war in South Sudan, a mere two years after independence, and making good all the predictions by outsiders that South Sudanese will have limited capacity to build a peaceful nation" and "sounds of gunfight, traversed with heart-shaking mortar and tank blasts, and which have continued sporadically well into today Wednesday morning, have all spread fear in the population, leaving them hostage to the madness of a few power-hungry men...[the uncertainty centres on] the fate of political stability in the whole country."[36]
The SPLM-affiliated youth group condemned the attempted overthrow of Kiir and a statement read: "We the SPLM-concerned youth group rejects in totality the notion and culture of using violence as a means to attain, retain or transfer power. The conflict is not between the Dinka and Nuer, but between government and those who lost power in the July reshuffle. We urge security forces to act with restrain in order to avoid the conflict from taking an ethnic dimension".[67]
Reactions
- Supranational
An African Union mediation team arrived in Juba on 19 December with representatives from Ethiopia, Kenya, Uganda and Rwanda. South Sudan government spokesman Ateny Wek Ateny said: "The African Union is till now meeting with the president. Their message is that they are trying to broker peace between the two forces," while he added "Bor has surrendered actually because the forces that were in Bor were mainly loyal to Machar. They control the town but government forces are trying to retake the town."[68]
The Organization of Islamic Cooperation's General Sectariat and office of Ekmeleddin İhsanoğlu condemned the coup saying: "Within the framework of ensuring security and stability in the region and stressing the promotion of good-neighborliness among states of the region, especially between the Republics of the Sudan and Southern Sudan, the OIC General Secretariat condemned the attempted coup which took place yesterday morning in the Republic of Southern Sudan".[69]
United Nations Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon's Special Representative for South Sudan Hilde Johnson issued a statement that read UNMISS was "deeply concerned" about the fighting and that "as the Special Representative of the Secretary-General I urge all parties in the fighting to cease hostilities immediately and exercise restraint. I have been in touch regularly with the key leaders, including at the highest levels to call for calm."[20] On 17 December, Ban spoke to Kiir calling for the government to provide an "offer of dialogue to its opponents and to resolve their respective differences peacefully."[70] Later, the United Nations Security Council was also told of as many as 500 deaths, 800 people injured and 20,000 seeking refuge at UN centres. French Ambassador and UNSC President for December Gérard Araud said: "Fighting is on ethnic lines, which could result in a very dangerous situation" and the UNMIS has the authority to use force if necessary.[34] On 22 December, UN Humanitarian Coordinator in South Sudan Toby Lanzer wrote on Twitter from the UN base in Bor that over 15,000 people were sheltering there and that "things are changing by the hour. We are under intense pressure here, as are other locations in Jonglei. Massive setback for South Sudan."[5] On 24 December, after the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay expressed concern about the conflict, the discovery of mass graves and the arrests of hundreds of civilians in the searches of homes and hotels, the UNSC voted to add about 6,000 international troops and 1,323 police officers to the existing over 7,600 UNMISS' personnel, including about 900 police personnel.[50] The resolution was passed under Chapter VII of the UN Charter which authorises the use of force; at the same time the SC demanded an immediate cessation of hostilities and opening a dialogue between the rival factions. The additional troops would come from other UN missions in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), Côte d’Ivoire, Liberia and neighbouring Sudan's Darfur and Abyei regions,[71] where the latter also have an interest in South Sudan. Ban said: "We have reports of horrific attacks. Tes of thousands have fled their homes...innocent civilians are being targeted because of their ethnicity." He also suggested targeted attacks could constitute war crimes or crimes against humanity, but warned that "this is a political crisis which requires a peaceful, political solution."[72] The resolution also answered India's concerns, as they have over 2,000 of the 7,000 troops in the country, over the UNMISS candidate by gaining the support of France, the U.S., Russia, Guatemala and Pakistan (the latter two of which are troop contributors). India's concerns entailed responsibility for protection of civilians as part of peacekeeping operations, with India suggesting the upsurge in violence could unleash a civil war which would "alter the terms of reference of the presence of UNMISS [in regards to the original 2011 mandate of resolution 1996] completely;" India also suggested the conflicts raison d'etre as being one of inter-tribal or ethnic conflict, which was reflected in the first paragraph of the resolution. Both sides thus needed to agree to dialogue to resolve their differences. India's other concern was that its troops were deployed to remote areas in small numbers and are thus at the front of the "brunt of the violence" and need to be augmented. The resolutions endorsement that UNMISS has the right to take action to protect its mandate "gives our peacekeepers the necessary flexibility to respond to the attacks against their positions."[73] The UN reported that over 81,000 people were displaced by 25 December[11] and up to 90,000, including 58,000 at UN facilities.[74]
- States
- Africa
After the fighting spread, South African government spokesman, Clayson Monyela, condemned the coup attempt stating "South Africa firmly believes that respect for democracy and human rights are essential to the governance of all African countries and that all violent means to overthrow legitimate governments must be rejected...It is therefore highly unfortunate that an attempt was allegedly made to undermine the stability of the country."[75]
Nigeria also condemned the coup and said that its "information further reveals that government forces were able to beat back the rebels...Destruction of property on a level yet to be determined has also been reported”.[76] Gambia's Secretary General and Head of the Civil Service and Minister of Presidential Affairs Momodou Sabally said that the attempted overthrow of Kiir's government was unacceptable and that the protagonists of the attempt should desist from destabilising the country.[77]
- Europe
The Government of the United Kingdom announced it was sending an aircraft to evacuate its citizens from Juba on 19 December. The Foreign and Commonwealth Office had also warned against all travel to South Sudan and temporarily withdrew some staff and dependants from the British embassy.[35] In his first Urbi et Orbi Christmas message, Pope Francis called for "social harmony in South Sudan, where current tensions have already caused numerous victims and are threatening peaceful coexistence in that young state."[78]
- North America
In the first days of the conflict, the U.S. embassy in the country reported that while it was aware of "security incidents and sporadic gunfire in multiple locations" it could not confirm "that gunfire and insecurity have fully ceased. The embassy recommends that all U.S. citizens exercise extra caution at all times. The U.S. Embassy will continue to closely monitor the security environment in South Sudan, with particular attention to Juba city and its immediate surroundings, and will advise US citizens further if the security situation changes."[20] The embassy's Twitter account reported that it denied rumours Machar had taken refuge at the base[28] and also reiterated warnings for its citizens to "remain calm."[79] On 18 December, the U.S. embassy asked all its citizens to "depart immediately."[34] President Barack Obama then called for an end to the fighting amid warning of being at the "precipice" of civil war. This followed his 18 December statement that he had deployed 45 troops to the country to protect U.S. personnel and interests while warning that "recent fighting threatens to plunge South Sudan back into the dark days of its past. Fighting to settle political scores or to destabilise the government must stop immediately. Inflammatory rhetoric and targeted violence must cease. All sides must listen to the wise counsel of their neighbours, commit to dialogue and take immediate steps to urge calm and support reconciliation. South Sudan's leaders must recognise that compromise with one's political enemy is difficult; but recovering from unchecked violence and unleashed hatred will prove much harder."[38] He also condemned the coup.[80] After the evacuation of some citizens from the country, in accordance with the War Powers Act, Obama wrote to Speaker John Boehner and Senate President Pro-Tempore Patrick J. Leahy that he was ready to take more action to support U.S. interests and citizens there.[81] The country's envoy to South Sudan, Donald Booth, said prior to 25 December that "we notice that the African Union has said there is Christmas season upon us, and called for all parties to cease hostilities. We support that call."[7] Secretary of State John Kerry called on both parties to "accept a cessation of hostilities and begin mediated political talks. At the same time, U.S. Defense Departement's Africom announced the deployment of a "platoon-sized" USMC contingent to neighbouring Uganda in order to protect U.S. citizens and facilities in South Sudan and to prepare for possible further evacuations. This was in addition to the nearly 100 U.S. troops in South Sudan, including the reinforcement of security at the U.S. embassy. Further, about roughly 150 USMC personnel were in Djibouti on 24 December, along with cargo planes and helicopters.[65]
Analysis
Radio Tamazuj suggested resolution of the conflict as:[30]
At minimum a process of political reconciliation must begin between Salva Kiir, Riek Machar, Pag’an Amum and their supporters. Reinstating the opposition leaders with some of their powers either within the government or party may be an option on the table. The worst option would be seeking a military solution in the style of the Khartoum regime which has tried for ten years to crush rebels in Darfur, the Nuba Mountains and Blue Nile. War would lead to immense suffering of the population. Perhaps the most likely scenario is something in between, with fast spreading military clashes all over the country, mounting pressure from the international community and finally a painstaking national reconciliation process.
Ironically, the best bet for Salva Kiir to remain in power might indeed be to count on the support of President Omar Al Bashir, whom he fought over several decades. If the situation continues to run out of hand, the Nuer militia might take control over oilfields in their homelands, which would cut off the oil flow to Khartoum, endangering the stability of the economy and thereby putting the regime at risk of a popular uprising. Sudan’s main interest then is to protect the flow of oil to the north. In one scenario, Khartoum would move to help defend the oil wells and facilities by military means, while providing other forms of support to Salva Kiir such as air power. In another scenario, Khartoum would divide and again rule South Sudan by supporting its former Nuer allies like Riek Machar.
Kiir's swapping of his traditional suit and cowboy hat for military fatigues, was noted by commentators and analysts to be indicative of the gravity of the situation. Other noticeable and concerning events from the rebellion were the division within the presidential guards that had been internationally trained and noted for their unity despite ethnic diversity. This was read as showing strains after decades of conflict with "a rebel-movement turned government that is riven by infighting between former warlords vying for a piece of this oil-rich new nation." Kiir's televised statement also controversially made reference to Machar as determined to "persistently pursue his actions of the past," in reference to a 1991 split that led to a massacre between the Dinka and Nuer minority. It was also suggested that the spark behind the revolt were rumours of arrests after "a series of publci [sic] statements criticising Kiir's increasingly dictatorial style." South Sudanese politics has been criticised for the ethnic dominance of the Dinka tribes, being derogatively referred to as a "Dinkocracy." U.S. Ambassador to South Sudan Susan D. Page suggested that there was not as much support for Machar in an organised manner, but a general discontent over the economic and political spheres tied to crackdown on personal freedoms that resulted in a national disunity of an identity only forged by war.[21]
The ICG's Casie Copeland said of the ethnic fighting that "even if there is a political deal, it will be very difficult to put the genie back in the bottle" and that it was concerning that UNMISS had "not begun patrolling in Juba and has not reached areas where civilians are concentrated." Copeland added that "it appears both sides are fighting for their political survival. The impact of this fighting is going to shape the future of South Sudan. Parts of Juba have been reduced to rubble. Ethnic tensions have been brought into the open with devastating impact, and the political dispensation of South Sudan is going to be shaped by what's happened in the last few days."[21] The ICG later added: "The scenario many feared but dared not contemplate looks frighteningly possible: South Sudan, the world's newest state, is now arguably on the cusp of a civil war."[36]
See also
- Central African Republic conflict under the Djotodia administration, neighbouring Central African Republic's conflict started a few months previously and has also been cloaked in a veneer of ethno-religious conflict.[23]
References
- ^ "Ugandan troops deployed in South Sudan capital: report". The Daily Star. Retrieved 25 December 2013.
- ^ "South Sudan rebels seize key town of Bor: army". The Daily Star. 19 December 2013. Retrieved 19 December 2013.
- ^ a b "South Sudan president says government troops retake key town". The Daily Star. 24 December 2013. Retrieved 24 December 2013.
- ^ a b "U.S. military aircraft hit in South Sudan". The Daily Star. 21 December 2013. Retrieved 21 December 2013.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i "S Sudan loses control of key oil-rich city". Al Jazeera English. Retrieved 23 December 2013.
- ^ "South Sudanese government loses key oil capital". Press TV. 23 December 2013.
- ^ a b c Thomson Reuters Foundation. "South Sudan rebel leader sets out conditions for talks". Trust.org. Retrieved 24 December 2013.
{{cite web}}
:|author=
has generic name (help) - ^ a b c Daniel Howden in Juba. "South Sudan: the state that fell apart in a week". The Guardian. Retrieved 24 December 2013.
- ^ a b http://www.thestate.com/2013/12/18/3165232/army-defections-as-south-sudan.html Cite error: The named reference "500killed" was defined multiple times with different content (see the help page).
- ^ "Four hurt as gunfire hits US military plane sent to evacuate Americans from South Sudan". Worldnews.nbcnews.com. Retrieved 23 December 2013.
- ^ a b c Cite error: The named reference
xmas
was invoked but never defined (see the help page). - ^ a b "Indian peacekeepers prevented more casualties in S Sudan: UN official". Zee News. 22 December 2013. Retrieved 22 December 2013.
- ^ "2 Kenyans killed in South Sudan fighting". Capitalfm.co.ke. Retrieved 24 December 2013.
- ^ "U.S. Marines poised to enter South Sudan". CNN. Retrieved 24 December 2013.
- ^ a b "Four hurt as gunfire hits US military plane sent to evacuate Americans from South Sudan". Worldnews.nbcnews.com. Retrieved 24 December 2013.
- ^ http://allafrica.com/stories/201312220007.html
- ^ a b c d Musaazi Namiti (17 December 2013). "Analysis: Struggle for power in South Sudan". Al Jazeera. Retrieved 17 December 2013.
- ^ a b c d "South Sudan violence spreads from capital". Al Jazeera English. 4 October 2011. Retrieved 18 December 2013.
- ^ a b "South Sudan gripped by power struggle". Al Jazeera. 28 July 2013. Retrieved 17 December 2013.
- ^ a b c d e f g "Heavy gunfire rocks South Sudan capital". Al Jazeera. 16 December 2013. Retrieved 17 December 2013.
- ^ a b c d e f g Hannah McNeish (17 December 2013). "South Sudan teeters on the brink". Retrieved 17 December 2013.
- ^ a b c d e f "S Sudan president says coup attempt 'foiled'". Al Jazeera. 16 December 2013. Retrieved 17 December 2013.
- ^ a b Abdi Ismail Samatar. "Central Africa crisis: Cherchez La France". Al Jazeera English. Retrieved 24 December 2013.
- ^ a b Hannah McNeish. "Witnesses describe atrocities in South Sudan". Al Jazeera English. Retrieved 25 December 2013.
- ^ a b c d e "South Sudan quashes coup attempt, says President Kiir". BBC. 16 December 2013. Retrieved 17 December 2013.
- ^ "Peter Adwok : 'President's order to disarm Nuer guards caused mutiny and chaos in South Sudan'". Radio Tamazuj. Retrieved 20 December 2013.
- ^ a b "Attempted coup in South Sudan". The Sydney Morning Herald. Agence France-Presse. 17 December 2013. Retrieved 17 December 2013.
- ^ a b Carl Odera (16 December 2013). "Gunshots ring out in South Sudan capital after "attempted coup"". Reuters. Retrieved 17 December 2013.
- ^ a b c d "South Sudan clashes: 'Dozens of soldiers killed' in Juba". BBC. 17 December 2013. Retrieved 17 December 2013.
- ^ a b c "Nine questions about the South Sudan crisis: A guide for confused observers". Radio Tamazuj. Retrieved 20 December 2013.
- ^ "Three killed in Bor as Juba fighting spreads". Sudan Tribune. 17 December 2013. Retrieved 17 December 2013.
- ^ a b "Second day of deadly clashes in South Sudan". Al Jazeera. 17 December 2013. Retrieved 17 December 2013.
- ^ "South Sudan army loses control of flashpoint town - RTÉ News". Rte.ie. 19 February 2013. Retrieved 18 December 2013.
- ^ a b c "South Sudan death toll rises sharply". Al Jazeera English. Retrieved 18 December 2013.
- ^ a b c "South Sudan rebels take flashpoint town". Al Jazeera English. 4 October 2011. Retrieved 19 December 2013.
- ^ a b c d Hannah McNeish. "South Sudan's Machar speaks to Al Jazeera". Al Jazeera English. Retrieved 19 December 2013.
- ^ "UN says base in South Sudan stormed". Al Jazeera English. 4 October 2011. Retrieved 20 December 2013.
- ^ a b "Peacekeepers killed at South Sudan UN base". Al Jazeera English. 4 October 2011. Retrieved 20 December 2013.
- ^ "Oil workers at South Sudan U.N. base expected to be evacuated: U.N." Reuters. Retrieved 19 December 2013.
- ^ Eoin O'Cinneide (13 December 2013). "'Oil workers killed' in S Sudan fighting". Upstreamonline.com. Retrieved 19 December 2013.
- ^ a b James Copnall (1 January 1970). "South Sudan sees 'mass ethnic killings'". Bbc.co.uk. Retrieved 24 December 2013.
- ^ "Ugandan troops deployed in South Sudan capital: report". The Daily Star. Retrieved 20 December 2013.
- ^ Starr, Barbara (21 December 2013). "4 U.S. troops hurt in South Sudan gunfire". CNN. Retrieved 21 December 2013.
- ^ 3 US Military Aircraft Hit in S. Sudan, 4 Wounded
- ^ "US military aircraft hit in South Sudan". Al Jazeera English. Retrieved 23 December 2013.
- ^ "Defected Unity state army commander forms new interim administration -". Sudan Tribune. Retrieved 24 December 2013.
- ^ http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/23/world/africa/americans-evacuated-from-south-sudan.html?hp&_r=1&
- ^ a b "S Sudan army says strikes on rebels imminent". Al Jazeera English. 4 October 2011. Retrieved 24 December 2013.
- ^ "US envoy says S Sudan president open to talks". Al Jazeera English. Retrieved 24 December 2013.
- ^ a b "UN approves more S Sudan peacekeepers". Al Jazeera English. Retrieved 24 December 2013.
- ^ http://www.aljazeera.com/programmes/insidestory/2013/12/south-sudan-sliding-into-civil-war-2013122582314508387.html
- ^ "S Sudan says army has retaken rebel-held city". Al Jazeera English. Retrieved 24 December 2013.
- ^ "SPLA claims victory in Bor; most of Gadet's troops leave town". Radio Tamazuj. Retrieved 25 December 2013.
- ^ "UN warns South Sudan over alleged crimes against humanity". The Asian Age. Retrieved 24 December 2013.
- ^ http://www.aljazeera.com/video/africa/2013/12/kenyan-citizens-flee-south-sudan-fighting-2013122464210622792.html
- ^ http://www.sabc.co.za/news/a/7f931e804251254395dd9d3d86b55090/South-Sudan-says-fighting-rebels-in-oil-state-Upper-Nile's-capital
- ^ http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/world/rest-of-world/Fighting-rages-in-South-Sudan-as-UN-moves-to-boost-force/articleshow/27919541.cms
- ^ "At least 66 troops dead in South Sudan fighting: Doctor". Timesofindia.indiatimes.com. 17 December 2013. Retrieved 24 December 2013.
- ^ "South Sudan clashes 'kill 400-500' after coup claim". Bbc.co.uk. 18 December 2013. Retrieved 24 December 2013.
- ^ "South Sudan evacuation aircraft fired on, US troops hurt". Bbc.co.uk. 1 January 1970. Retrieved 24 December 2013.
- ^ "UN says mass graves discovered in South Sudan". The Irish Times. Retrieved 24 December 2013.
- ^ http://edition.cnn.com/2013/12/24/politics/south-sudan-explainer/
- ^ Jason Straziuso (25 December). "UN in South Sudan denies report of mass grave". The Daily Star.
{{cite web}}
: Check date values in:|date=
(help) - ^ "S Sudan leader says talks possible". Al Jazeera English. Retrieved 23 December 2013.
- ^ a b "Thousands killed as South Sudan slides toward civil war: UN". Timesofindia.indiatimes.com. 1 January 1970. Retrieved 25 December 2013.
- ^ "Parliament chief whip announces support for Kiir". Radio Tamazuj. Retrieved 20 December 2013.
- ^ 17 December 2013 (2 January 2013). "Sudan: Pro-SPLM Youth Group Condemns 'Coup Attempt'". allAfrica.com. Retrieved 20 December 2013.
{{cite web}}
: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link) - ^ Odera, Carl. "Troops clash in South Sudan, African states mediate". Reuters. Retrieved 19 December 2013.
- ^ "OIC condemns S. Sudan attempted coup". KUNA. Retrieved 20 December 2013.
- ^ "UPDATE 3-South Sudan says arrests 10, hunts ex-VP over foiled coup". Reuters. 4 June 2009. Retrieved 18 December 2013.
- ^ "Security Council doubles UN peacekeeping force in South Sudan in face of spreading conflict". Un.org. Retrieved 24 December 2013.
- ^ http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/25/world/africa/south-sudan-crisis.html?src=recg
- ^ http://zeenews.india.com/news/nation/un-resolution-addresses-indian-concerns-in-south-sudan-violence_899400.html
- ^ http://www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?NewsID=46825&Cr=South#.UrtLAnbFKM8
- ^ Location Settings. "Government condemns South Sudan coup". News24. Retrieved 20 December 2013.
- ^ "FG condemns coup in South Sudan". Tribune.com.ng. Retrieved 23 December 2013.
- ^ 23 December 2013. "Gambia Condemns Violence in South Sudan, Car". allAfrica.com. Retrieved 24 December 2013.
{{cite web}}
: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link) - ^ http://www.aljazeera.com/news/africa/2013/12/pope-calls-peace-south-sudan-syria-2013122512534510684.html
- ^ "Tweet". U.S. Mission in Juba. Twitter. 17 December 2013. Retrieved 17 December 2013.
- ^ Sodiq Adekunle. "Nigeria, Obama Condemn Crisis in South Sudan". Dailytimes.com.ng. Retrieved 24 December 2013.
- ^ http://thecaucus.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/12/22/obama-says-further-action-possible-in-south-sudan/?src=recg