Content deleted Content added
→Notice of requested move: new section |
→Notice of requested move: the requested move was hard to follow reasoning for, but, also you kept making links to the redirect page, after being asked not to, this is simple |
||
Line 4: | Line 4: | ||
This article is an improvement over a redirect to [[Salsola]], but it conflates the habit and the common name. Also, this article was created in the face of a requested move of [[Tumbleweed (disambiguation)]] to [[Tumbleweed]]. --[[User:Una Smith|Una Smith]] ([[User talk:Una Smith|talk]]) 03:36, 4 January 2009 (UTC) |
This article is an improvement over a redirect to [[Salsola]], but it conflates the habit and the common name. Also, this article was created in the face of a requested move of [[Tumbleweed (disambiguation)]] to [[Tumbleweed]]. --[[User:Una Smith|Una Smith]] ([[User talk:Una Smith|talk]]) 03:36, 4 January 2009 (UTC) |
||
:The requested move is still hard to understand. However, I asked you to wait until the discuss was over on that requested move to continue linking to the redirect to ''Salsola''. You seemed intent on ignoring that request. It made less work for me to just write the article. The intention ''is'' to conflate the habit and the common name for the purposes of this article and use the dab page for the common name redirects. |
|||
:When there are many things with the same name, but one is used far more commonly than others, on Wikipedia that one can be the name, then there is a dab page for the others. There is no purpose than in making the article about tumbleweeds called something like "Tumbleweed (weed)" or "Tumbleweed (plant)" with so many other competitors, but this name clearly leading ''in dictionaries'' as the primary meaning of the name. --[[User:KP Botany|KP Botany]] ([[User talk:KP Botany|talk]]) 03:42, 4 January 2009 (UTC) |
Revision as of 03:42, 4 January 2009
![]() | Plants Stub‑class | |||||||||
|
Notice of requested move
This article is an improvement over a redirect to Salsola, but it conflates the habit and the common name. Also, this article was created in the face of a requested move of Tumbleweed (disambiguation) to Tumbleweed. --Una Smith (talk) 03:36, 4 January 2009 (UTC)
- The requested move is still hard to understand. However, I asked you to wait until the discuss was over on that requested move to continue linking to the redirect to Salsola. You seemed intent on ignoring that request. It made less work for me to just write the article. The intention is to conflate the habit and the common name for the purposes of this article and use the dab page for the common name redirects.
- When there are many things with the same name, but one is used far more commonly than others, on Wikipedia that one can be the name, then there is a dab page for the others. There is no purpose than in making the article about tumbleweeds called something like "Tumbleweed (weed)" or "Tumbleweed (plant)" with so many other competitors, but this name clearly leading in dictionaries as the primary meaning of the name. --KP Botany (talk) 03:42, 4 January 2009 (UTC)